The UK Founder's Guide to Hiring Ad Experts

If you're a UK startup founder, you've probably felt the frustration. You're burning through cash on Google or Meta ads, the results are mediocre at best, and every "paid ad consultant" you speak to sounds the same. They promise the world, flash a few vanity metrics, and then deliver a report that tells you nothing you couldn't have figured out yourself. The search for a reliable expert who actually understands your business feels like a minefield.

Here's the brutal truth: the problem often isn't just the consultant you hired. The problem is a broken process. Most founders don't know how to properly vet and hire an ad expert because they're asking the wrong questions and looking for the wrong things. They treat it like hiring a plumber when they should be treating it like finding a co-founder for their growth engine. This guide is designed to fix that. It's not another list of generic interview questions. It's a founder's framework for finding a genuine expert in the UK who can become a partner in your growth, not just another line item on your P&L.

Why are my ads failing before I even hire someone?

Let’s get one thing straight. A world-class paid ads consultant cannot fix a broken business model. Pouring ad spend on a weak offer is like trying to fill a leaky bucket with a fire hose. The most common reason I see campaigns fail, especially for startups, has nothing to do with bidding strategies or ad creative. It's the foundations. Get these right, and you're 80% of the way there. Get them wrong, and you're just paying platforms like Google and Meta to tell people about a product nobody wants.

The first piece of the puzzle is your Ideal Customer Profile (ICP). Forget the demographic nonsense your last marketing hire put together. "SMEs in the tech sector with 50-200 employees based in London" is utterly useless. It tells you nothing of value and leads to generic ads that speak to absolutely no one. You need to define your customer by their pain. What is the specific, urgent, expensive, career-threatening nightmare that keeps them awake at 3 AM?

Your Head of Sales client isn't just a job title; she's a leader terrified of missing her quarterly target and having a very difficult conversation with the board. For a legal tech SaaS, the nightmare isn't 'needing better document management'; it's 'a junior associate missing a critical filing deadline, exposing the firm to a malpractice suit and reputational ruin.' Your ICP isn't a person; it's a problem state. Once you've isolated that nightmare, you can craft a message that they simply can't ignore.

The second, and arguably more important, piece is understanding your numbers. The most critical number isn't your Cost Per Lead (CPL) or your Return on Ad Spend (ROAS) from last month's failed campaign. It's your Customer Lifetime Value (LTV). Without knowing what a customer is truly worth to you in profit over their entire relationship with your business, you're flying blind. You can't possibly know what you can afford to spend to acquire one. This single calculation transforms your thinking from "How cheap can I get a lead?" to "How much can I afford to invest to acquire a high-value customer?" That's the mindset shift that unlocks scalable growth. A cheap lead that never converts is infinitely more expensive than a 'costly' lead that becomes a long-term, profitable customer.

I've built a simple calculator below to help you figure this out. Play around with the numbers. This isn't just an academic exercise; it's the financial bedrock of your entire paid acquisition strategy.

Consultant, Agency, or In-House? The UK Founder's Choice

Once your foundations are solid, the next question is who should manage your ads. This is a critical decision, and the right answer depends entirely on your stage, budget, and internal capabilities. There's no single "best" option, only the best option for *you*, right now. Too many UK startups either hire a junior in-house marketer too early or sign a crippling 12-month contract with a big agency that sees them as a small fish. Let's break down the real pros and cons for a startup.

An in-house hire seems appealing. They're 100% dedicated to your brand, immersed in your culture, and right there in the office (or Slack channel). This is great for a mature company with a proven marketing engine that needs optimisation. But for a startup? It can be a trap. A truly expert paid ads specialist is expensive, and you're unlikely to need them 40 hours a week. More often, founders hire a generalist who knows a little about a lot, but isn't a deep expert in the complex, ever-changing world of paid ads. This can lead to slow progress and costly mistakes.

A large advertising agency offers a team of specialists, fancy reporting dashboards, and the reassurance of a big name. The problem is, as a startup with a modest budget, you'll likely be assigned to their most junior account manager. The senior experts you met in the sales pitch will be nowhere to be seen, and your account becomes a training ground for their new hires. You get a standardised, cookie-cutter approach that rarely delivers the agile, test-and-learn mindset a startup desperately needs.

This is where a specialist paid ad consultant or a small, boutique agency often shines for startups. You get direct access to a senior-level expert who lives and breathes this stuff. They've seen what works (and what doesn't) across dozens of accounts, bringing a wealth of cross-industry experience. They're typically more flexible, more agile, and their success is directly tied to yours. The downside is that you are not their only client, and you need to be organised to get the most out of the relationship. It's a partnership, not a simple delegation. For many UK founders, this model provides the best balance of deep expertise and cost-effectiveness. The key is finding the right one, which is exactly what the rest of this guide is about. To help you decide, I've mapped out a simple decision flow below.

How to spot a top-tier UK consultant from the pretenders

So you've decided a consultant or small agency is the right fit. Now comes the hard part: finding a good one. The UK market is flooded with self-proclaimed "gurus" and "experts". Your job is to filter the top 1% from the rest. This isn't about their sales pitch; it's about a rigorous vetting process that tests their actual expertise.

Step 1: The Case Study Interrogation.
Any consultant worth their salt will have case studies. But don't just glance at the headlines. You need to pick them apart. A good case study isn't a fluffy story; it's a detailed breakdown of a problem, a strategy, and a measurable result. Look for specifics. -> Instead of "We increased their revenue," look for "We generated £107k in revenue at 618% ROAS for a prize draw company using Meta Ads." -> Instead of "We got them more leads," look for "We reduced their cost per lead by 84% for a B2B environmental controls company using a combination of LinkedIn and Meta Ads." -> Ask them to walk you through one that is relevant to your business. What was the biggest challenge? What was the key insight that unlocked the results? What failed along the way? If they can't talk about their failures and what they learned, they're either inexperienced or dishonest. This is also where you should be looking for experience in your specific niche. If you are a SaaS startup, ask to see SaaS case studies. We've worked with many, achieving results like reducing a £100 CPA to just £7 for a medical job matching platform. That kind of specific, relevant experience is what you're paying for.

Step 2: The Free Consultation Litmus Test.
This is your single most important vetting tool. Many consultants and agencies (including us) offer a free initial consultation or strategy review. This is not a sales call. This is a live audition. You should come away from this call with at least one, if not several, actionable insights you could implement yourself *tomorrow* to improve your ads. They should be asking you tough questions about your business, your LTV, your ICP, and your offer. They should be challenging your assumptions. If all they do is ask about your budget and tell you how great they are, run for the hills. A true expert can't help but diagnose problems and suggest solutions, even on an initial call. They should be demonstrating their value, not just talking about it. This is how you can find an ad expert that genuinely drives ROI, by testing their expertise before you commit.

Step 3: The Proposal Review.
After the call, they'll send a proposal. A red flag is a generic, copy-paste document that just outlines a package of services. A great proposal is a strategic document. It should recap their understanding of your specific challenges and goals. It should outline a clear, phased approach: Month 1 is for account audit, setup, and initial testing; Month 2 is for optimising winning campaigns and exploring new angles; Month 3 is for scaling. It should define what success looks like with clear KPIs (Key Performance Indicators). It should feel like a plan for your business, not a menu from theirs. And be wary of anyone who promises specific results. In paid advertising, you can't promise anything. An expert will talk about a clear process for *finding* results, not guaranteeing them.

Step 4: The Reference Check Fallacy.
This might be a contrarian view, but if you've done the first three steps properly, you shouldn't need to ask for references. Think about it: no one is ever going to give you a bad reference. Tbh, if a potential client asks us for references after we've shown them detailed case studies and given them a free, in-depth account review, it's a red flag for us. It signals a fundamental lack of trust that will likely plague the entire relationship. Your confidence should come from the rigor of your own vetting process, not from a rehearsed phone call with one of their happy clients. Trust the evidence you've gathered yourself. The entire point of a proper vetting process for UK paid ad agencies is to build that trust based on demonstrated expertise.

What should I actually be paying for ads in the UK?

This is the million-dollar—or rather, million-pound—question. The answer is, of course, "it depends". But that's not helpful. While every account is different, there are some general benchmarks for the UK market that can help you gauge whether your performance is in the right ballpark. These numbers are based on our experience running campaigns for dozens of clients across various industries. Remember, these are averages; your actual costs will be affected by your industry, targeting, creative quality, and landing page conversion rate.

Generally, for conversion-focused campaigns in a developed market like the UK, you can expect a Cost Per Click (CPC) somewhere in the £0.50 to £1.50 range on platforms like Meta. Then, a decent landing page should convert between 10% and 30% of that traffic for a simple action like a lead form submission or an email signup. Doing the maths, this puts your Cost Per Lead (CPL) or Cost Per Acquisition (CPA) for a signup in the range of £1.60 to £15.00. We ran a campaign for an app recently that achieved over 45,000 signups at under £2 per signup, which is on the excellent end of that scale.

For eCommerce or higher-commitment B2B leads (like a demo request for a SaaS product), the conversion rates are naturally lower, usually between 2% and 5%. This means your cost per purchase or qualified lead will be significantly higher. Using the same CPC range, you could be looking at a CPA of £10 to £75. For high-ticket B2B, this can be even higher. We've seen CPLs of around $22 (£17-£18) for B2B decision-makers on LinkedIn, which is considered very efficient on that platform. The main thing is that your CPA must be sustainable when compared to your Customer Lifetime Value (LTV). If your LTV is £10,000, paying £75 for a customer is a fantastic deal.

The chart below visualises these typical CPA ranges. If your costs are wildly outside these brackets, it's a strong indicator that something is wrong—either with your targeting, your creative, your offer, or your website. A good consultant's first job is to diagnose why and bring those costs in line. If you're consistently seeing a high CPA, it might be a sign of a deeper issue, often leading to low UK ad ROI which has its own set of root causes to investigate.

I’ve hired someone. Now what?

Signing the contract is not the end of the process; it's the beginning. The first 90 days with a new consultant or agency are critical for setting the tone of the entire relationship. Your job as a founder is to set them up for success. This isn't about micromanagement. It's about creating a framework of clear communication, aligned goals, and mutual accountability.

First, the onboarding process should be thorough. Provide them with access to everything they need upfront: ad accounts, analytics, your CRM, and any past performance data. More importantly, give them access to your brain. Schedule a deep dive session to walk them through your business model, your customer's nightmare (as we discussed), your LTV calculations, and your overarching business goals for the next quarter and year. The more context they have, the faster they can start delivering value.

Second, establish a clear communication rhythm. A weekly check-in call and a simple, end-of-week summary email are often enough. Avoid constant ad-hoc requests on Slack. The report you receive should be concise and focused on the metrics that actually matter to your business growth, not a data dump of vanity metrics like impressions and clicks. It should answer three questions: 1) What did we do this week? 2) What were the results (leads, sales, CPA, ROAS)? 3) What are we doing next week based on what we learned? This creates a clear feedback loop and ensures the strategy is constantly evolving.

Finally, treat them like a partner, not a vendor. A good consultant will challenge you. They might tell you your landing page is the problem, not their ads. They might suggest your offer isn't compelling enough. Listen to them. You hired them for their expertise, so be open to it, even when it's uncomfortable. This collaborative approach is what separates a successful client-consultant relationship from a frustrating one. Managing this relationship effectively is a skill in itself, and a crucial part of the founder's framework for managing external paid ad partners for maximum ROI.

Ultimately, finding and hiring the right paid ads consultant in the UK is one of the most important investments a startup founder can make. It's not a cost centre; it's an engine for predictable, scalable growth. By shifting your mindset from simply 'hiring a freelancer' to 'recruiting a strategic partner' and following a rigorous vetting process, you dramatically increase your chances of success. You stop burning cash and start building a sustainable customer acquisition machine.

This process takes effort, but the payoff is immense. A top-tier consultant won't just manage your ads; they will help you understand your customer more deeply, refine your offer, and build a more resilient business. If you’ve read this far and feel you're ready to find that kind of partner, the next logical step is a conversation.

We offer a completely free, no-obligation 20-minute strategy session for UK founders. We’ll take a look at your current ad accounts, discuss your goals, and give you honest, actionable advice you can use right away—whether you decide to work with us or not. Consider it the first step in your vetting process.

I've detailed my main recommendations for you below: