TLDR;
- Founders assume Meta and Google Ads should yield roughly similar acquisition costs if targeting the same audience, leading them to burn budget on Meta prospecting when it fails to convert at search-level efficiency.
- Our dataset from a medical job matching SaaS shows Meta prospecting hit an absolute floor of £35 per acquisition, while Google Search dropped as low as £7—a massive 400% higher CPA on Meta.
- The data proves that pushing top-of-funnel ads to a narrow professional niche (nurses) on Meta simply cannot compete with the active, high-intent queries captured by Google Search for specific nursing specialties.
- I've detailed my main recommendations for you below: interactive models and benchmark figures so you can test these exact metrics against your own funnel.
Tbh, if you spend enough time reading forums, you'll eventually convince yourself that there's some hidden trick to making Meta ads perfectly mirror the efficiency of Google Search. A lot of founders come to me frustrated, convinced their creative is broken because their social ads are bleeding cash compared to their search campaigns. They assume that if they just tweak the copy enough, Meta will magically deliver £5 signups for a highly specific B2B SaaS product.
But the data tells a completely different story. I wanted to look exactly at why this happens. What causes Meta prospecting campaigns to sustain a 400% higher cost per acquisition compared to targeted Google search placements in healthcare recruitment? It's a specific question, but the math behind it explains why so many SaaS campaigns fail to scale.
I've pulled the raw data from a recent campaign we ran. We were working with a software-as-a-service (SaaS) product that operates as a medical job matching platform. The specific challenge was targeting a narrow, highly qualified audience of nurses to drive platform signups. The goal was simple: find the best ad platform to reach this audience at scale, and at the lowest cost per signup. We ran this through our ongoing optimization process, heavily split-testing across both Meta and Google. The findings, quite frankly, expose exactly why you shouldn't expect social prospecting to behave like search.
What does the actual dataset look like?
Before we look at the numbers, let's establish exactly what this data is. This isn't some generic industry report patched together from random surveys. This is empirical data from a single client account in the hiring and software niche, captured during an intensive optimization sprint. We tested multiple ad platforms simultaneously to find where we could acquire users efficiently.
On Meta, we ran image ads targeting a top-of-funnel prospecting audience as well as a retargeting audience. We tested different sales copy frameworks—specifically Problem-Agitate-Solution (PAS) and Attention-Interest-Desire-Action (AIDA). On Google Ads, we went much broader on placement types but narrower on intent. We tested automated campaigns tailored to various nursing specialties, Discovery campaigns (spanning YouTube and Gmail), and Performance Max campaigns. Both platforms directed traffic to the exact same landing page: the start page of the software product, where users could click a call-to-action button to enter the signup flow.
To conduct this research, I mapped out the starting and optimized CPA (Cost Per Acquisition) figures across all tested ad sets and campaigns. I then calculated the percentage decreases as we binned the underperforming targeting options and reallocated budget to the winners. The results highlight a fundamental difference in platform mechanics.
Baseline vs Optimised CPA Benchmarks
Cost per signup benchmarks from our medical job matching SaaS dataset, comparing the highest initial costs to the lowest optimised floors.
Data source: Internal client campaign data for a nursing job matching platform.
Why does Meta prospecting hit a floor at £35?
Let's look at the Meta data first. When we launched the initial top-of-funnel prospecting campaigns, we tested multiple targeting options. The highest cost we saw was £85 per signup. That is brutally expensive for a software trial/signup, and it's exactly the kind of number that makes founders panic and turn off their ads completely.
Through our optimization process—which involves ruthlessly turning off everything that underperforms and keeping the targeting options, ad sets, and creatives that work—we managed to bring that cost down significantly. We saw the CPA drop to a low of £35. Mathematically, reducing an £85 acquisition cost to £35 is a 58% decrease. In any normal scenario, cutting your CPA by more than half is a massive win.
But why did it stop at £35? Why couldn't we get it lower? The reality of Meta prospecting is that you are paying to interrupt people. When we target nurses on Facebook or Instagram, they aren't actively looking for a new job in that exact second. They are scrolling through pictures of their mates or watching videos. We are buying impression volume to find a tiny fraction of a narrow audience that might be mildly dissatisfied with their current role. Even with strong PAS copy—highlighting the problem of their current job and presenting the platform as the solution—the conversion rate from impression to signup hits a natural ceiling.
Budget Allocation Efficiency by Platform Floor
Visualising how much more budget is consumed on Meta to acquire a single user compared to the highly efficient Google Search baseline.
How does Google Search capture high intent so cheaply?
Now, contrast that with the Google Ads data. When we started testing Google, the initial highest cost was actually worse than Meta—sitting at a shocking £185 per signup (over £100 average before optimization). If you only looked at week one, you'd probably bin the whole channel.
But here is where the data gets interesting. We were running automated campaigns specifically for all the different nursing specialties they were targeting. This is the deciding variable. On Google Search, we aren't interrupting a nurse while they scroll. We are showing an ad to a specialised nurse who has actively typed something like "paediatric nursing jobs near me" into a search engine. That is pure, unfiltered intent.
By taking the Google campaigns through our optimization process—again, turning off the underperforming keywords, placements, and ads, and keeping only the ones that proved efficient—we saw the cost per signup plummet. The lowest cost we achieved was an incredible £7. That is a 93% decrease from the initial £100+ highs.
Let's do the math on the final floor costs: £35 on Meta versus £7 on Google.
(£35 / £7) = 5.
That means the Meta CPA is exactly 5 times higher, which translates to a 400% higher cost per acquisition compared to Google Search.
Budget Reallocation Simulator
Calculate the net impact on user signups if you shift budget from the £35 Meta CPA to the £7 Google Search CPA.
Can better ad copy fix poor audience intent?
A lot of marketers will tell you that the reason your Meta ads aren't converting at Google levels is because your creative is rubbish. To an extent, creative testing is necessary. In this dataset, we tested multiple versions of ad copy on Meta. We explicitly used a Problem-Agitate-Solution framework in one version, starting with the problem (frustrations in nursing) and presenting the platform as a solution. We also tested Attention-Interest-Desire-Action (AIDA) frameworks.
We even included a tagline and a direct call-to-action button in the actual ad design on Meta, because the data showed us this increases click-through rates. And it did work. It helped us drop the Meta CPA from £85 to £35. But no amount of clever AIDA copywriting can manufacture immediate, urgent intent in a demographic that is just casually browsing social media. The copy can only convert the small percentage of the audience that is already somewhat receptive.
Google Ads, particularly search placements, bypass the need to aggressively agitate a problem. The user is already agitated. They are already searching for a solution. When you bid on specific nursing specialties, you are meeting a demand that already exists, which is why the CPA compresses down to £7.
Intent Targeting Layering Framework
Layer 1: Broad Prospecting (Meta Top-of-Funnel)
Targeting users based on job titles (Nurses) or interests. High volume, low immediate intent. Resulted in an £85 initial CPA, optimised down to a floor of £35.
Layer 2: Platform Retargeting (Meta MoFu/BoFu)
Re-engaging users who previously interacted with the ads or visited the start page. Higher conversion rate than cold prospecting, assisting in driving down the blended Meta CPA.
Layer 3: Explicit Search Intent (Google Search)
Targeting users actively querying specific nursing specialties. Highest intent, lowest friction. Resulted in the lowest acquisition cost of the dataset at just £7 per signup.
Why do SaaS campaigns inevitably plateau?
It's quite normal for software campaigns to plateau. The data clearly shows that your spend on a platform like Meta will eventually hit a floor (in this case, £35) where you can't scale further without seeing higher CPAs. There is a limited number of people likely to convert for a specific niche product like a medical job matching platform at any given time.
When you've maxed out the pool of people likely to convert on Meta ads, you have to accept the unit economics of that channel. You can't force Meta to behave like Google. If your customer lifetime value supports a £35 acquisition cost, fair play—crack on and run the ads. But if you need leads under £10, the data proves you have to shift your budget to capture active search intent.
This all goes to say: paid advertising isn't just about throwing money at Facebook and hoping the algorithm works it out. You need to be pragmatic about where your audience is and what state of mind they are in when you reach them. The 93% decrease in Google CPA didn't happen by accident; it was the result of a rigorous optimization protocol that cut the wastage and leaned heavily into the specific nursing specialties that actually converted.
Traffic Intent Bottleneck Diagnostic
Model the drop-off difference between interrupting a broad audience (Meta) vs capturing intent (Google) based on the cost efficiencies in the data.
How should you structure your campaigns moving forward?
If you're pulling your hair out over high acquisition costs on Meta, stop obsessing over your ad copy for a minute and look at your platform mechanics. Meta is a powerful tool for driving volume and nurturing through retargeting, but it fundamentally lacks the active intent of a Google Search query. Our dataset proves this: no amount of optimization could push the Meta CPA below £35, while Google effortlessly hit £7 once we dialed in the nursing specialties.
You need a detailed strategy plan that maps out the different campaign types you want to test, backed by real targeting research. If you'd like to explore whether you can see similar results, find out what ad platform is actually right for your offer, or discover how low your own CPA could drop through proper optimization, I'd like to invite you to book a free initial consultation. We can look at your data together and chat about what strategy might actually work for you.
Cite this Research & Data
If referencing this research, data, or strategy in your publication, please use the attribution below.
Lukas Holschuh
Founder, Growth & Advertising Consultant
Great campaigns fail without expertise. Lukas and his team provide the missing strategy, optimizing your entire advertising funnel—from ad creatives and copy to landing page design.
Backed by a proven track record across SaaS, eLearning, and eCommerce, they don't just run ads; they engineer systems that convert. A data-driven partnership focused on tangible revenue growth.