TLDR;
- Most people assume retargeting is a cheap, easy win for cutting acquisition costs. It is often touted as the most efficient part of the funnel.
- The data from this 7,400-lead eLearning campaign shows the opposite: retargeting leads were actually 58% more expensive than the main cold prospecting campaigns (£9.82 vs £6.23 CPL).
- The real driver of cost wasn't the funnel stage, but the offer itself. A different 'cold' campaign for a "Data Analytics" course pulled in leads at just £3.94—less than half the cost of retargeting. Cost Per Lead is a misleading metric if you do not look at the whole picture.
- I have built a few interactive tools below from the campaign data, including a funnel economics simulator and a CAC affordability calculator, to show you where the real costs are and how to properly measure the value of a lead.
Everyone says the same thing: retargeting is where the easy money is. It is the part of the funnel where you mop up all that 'low-hanging fruit'—the people who have already shown interest—for a fraction of what it costs to find someone new. It is supposed to be cheaper, faster, more efficient. But is it really?
It is one of those bits of received wisdom you hear so often you just stop questioning it. But when you are spending tens of thousands of pounds on ads, you cannot afford to run on assumptions. You need to know what is actually working. So, I decided to dig into a recent account to answer a simple question: How do retargeting funnel stages really stack up against cold prospecting when it comes to cost efficiency?
To do this, I have pulled the data from a single, substantial Meta Ads account we managed for a client in the eLearning space. This is not a theoretical model; it is a real-world dataset covering a seven-month period from March to October 2024. Across all campaigns, we spent just shy of £50,000 and generated 7,394 leads for their career training courses. It is a clean, straightforward account with distinct campaigns for top-of-funnel (TOFU) prospecting and middle-of-funnel (MOFU) retargeting, making it perfect for this kind of analysis.
My goal here is to get past the surface-level metrics and figure out what is actually driving costs and, more importantly, what is driving value. What you find might challenge a few common beliefs about how funnels are supposed to work.
So, is retargeting actually cheaper?
Let us get straight to the point. The common wisdom says that your Cost Per Lead (CPL) for a retargeting audience should be significantly lower than for a cold audience. These are warm leads, after all. They know the brand. They have been to the website. They should convert more easily.
When I isolated the campaigns by funnel stage, the numbers told a very different story. The main top-of-funnel campaign, using native Meta Lead Forms to capture details from a completely cold audience, brought in 4,199 leads at an average CPL of £6.23. Now, look at the retargeting campaign, which targeted website visitors and ad engagers. It generated 61 leads at a CPL of £9.82.
That is not a small difference. The 'cheap' retargeting leads were 58% more expensive than the 'expensive' cold leads. This completely flips the script on what most marketers would expect. It was not even close.
To make it even clearer, let us look at all the major lead generation campaigns we ran. The only campaigns with a higher CPL were tiny, experimental ones where we tested cost-cap bidding and they failed to get any real traction. Among the campaigns that actually delivered volume, retargeting was the least cost-efficient on a per-lead basis.
Cost Per Lead: Prospecting vs. Retargeting
A direct comparison of average Cost Per Lead (CPL) from the eLearning account, broken down by the primary prospecting (TOFU) and retargeting (MOFU) campaigns.
So, what is going on here? Why would it cost more to convert someone who is already familiar with the business? This is where you have to look beyond the headline CPL and break down the mechanics of the funnel.
What is really driving the cost difference?
A Cost Per Lead is just the result of two other metrics: how much it costs to get someone to click your ad (Cost Per Click, or CPC), and what percentage of those people then go on to become a lead (Conversion Rate, or CVR). The formula is simple: CPL = CPC / CVR. To understand why the retargeting CPL was so high, we need to look at these two inputs.
Let us compare the core TOFU Lead Form campaign with the MOFU Retargeting campaign.
For the TOFU campaign:
- Cost Per Click (CPC): £1.15
- Link Clicks to Leads CVR: 18.51% (4,199 leads from 22,679 clicks)
For the MOFU campaign:
- Cost Per Click (CPC): £1.90
- Link Clicks to Leads CVR: 19.37% (61 leads from 315 clicks)
The numbers here are revealing. As you might expect, the conversion rate for the retargeting audience was slightly better. At 19.37%, they were a bit more likely to convert than the cold audience at 18.51%. This makes sense. They have seen the brand before, so there is less friction.
But look at the CPC. It cost £1.90 to get a click from the retargeting audience, a massive 65% more than the £1.15 CPC for the cold audience. This huge jump in click cost completely wiped out the small gain in conversion rate, and then some. This is the sole reason the CPL ended up being so much higher.
Why would the CPC be so much higher for a retargeting audience? It is a simple case of supply and demand. Your retargeting audience is, by definition, much smaller than a broad prospecting audience. You are competing with every other advertiser who is also trying to reach that same, valuable pool of users who have shown some intent. Platforms like Meta know these users are more likely to convert, so the auction price to get your ad in front of them goes up. You are paying a premium for that perceived quality.
The interactive simulator below lets you play with these numbers. You can see for yourself how even a small change in CPC can have a massive impact on your final CPL, and how a much higher conversion rate is needed to offset more expensive traffic.
Funnel Economics Simulator
Select a baseline scenario from the data and adjust the sliders to see how CPC and CVR impact your final Cost Per Lead.
Is CPL even the right metric to be looking at?
This brings us to a more fundamental question. We have established that, in this case, retargeting produced more expensive leads. So, should we just bin the retargeting campaign and pour all the money into prospecting? Not so fast.
Obsessing over CPL is a classic mistake. It treats all leads as equal, but they are not. A lead is just an enquiry. It is not a sale. The metric that actually matters to the business is the Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC) – how much you spend to get a paying customer. And the step between a lead and a customer is the sales process.
The data provided for this project gives us some important business metrics: the lifetime value (LTV) of a customer is £1,695, and the sales team's baseline close rate from leads is around 3% (or 1 in 35). This means, on average, they need 35 leads to make one sale.
So, let us calculate the CAC for our cold prospecting leads:
CAC = CPL / Close Rate
For the TOFU campaign, that is £6.23 / 0.03 = £207.67 per customer.
With an LTV of £1,695, a £208 CAC is fantastic. The LTV:CAC ratio is over 8:1, well above the healthy benchmark of 3:1. This is a profitable, scalable acquisition channel.
Now, what about the retargeting leads? Their CPL is £9.82. If they also convert at the baseline 3%, their CAC would be £9.82 / 0.03 = £327.33. That is still a healthy 5:1 ratio, but it is clearly less profitable.
However, the entire premise of retargeting is that these leads are not average. They should be more qualified, more engaged, and further down the buying journey. It is entirely plausible that the sales team converts them at a much higher rate. What if they convert at 5%, or even 10%? The picture changes completely.
- At a 5% close rate, the CAC for retargeting leads becomes £9.82 / 0.05 = £196.40.
- At a 10% close rate, the CAC drops to £9.82 / 0.10 = £98.20.
Suddenly, that more expensive lead is actually the more profitable one to acquire. The higher CPL is more than justified by the superior quality and higher purchase intent. Without knowing the actual close rate for each lead source, we cannot say for sure. But this demonstrates why looking only at CPL is a dangerous oversimplification.
The calculator below lets you model this out. You can plug in different CPLs and close rates to see what the true Customer Acquisition Cost is, and whether it makes sense for a business with a given customer LTV.
CAC Affordability Calculator
Enter your CPL and estimated close rate to find your true CAC and see if it is sustainable against your customer LTV.
Where are the biggest efficiency gains hiding?
The comparison between prospecting and retargeting has revealed some useful insights, but it is also a bit of a red herring. The most striking finding from this dataset is not about TOFU vs. MOFU at all. It is about the massive performance difference *within* the top of the funnel.
While the main 'Cyber Security' lead form campaign had a CPL of £6.23, we also ran a separate prospecting campaign for a 'Data Analytics' course. It used the same native lead form objective and targeted a similarly cold audience. The results were astounding.
The 'Data Analytics' campaign generated 719 leads at a CPL of just £3.94.
This is the real story. The most efficient campaign in the entire account was a cold prospecting campaign. It was 37% cheaper than the main prospecting campaign and 60% cheaper than the retargeting campaign. The offer was simply a much better fit for the audience we could reach on Meta, or it faced less competition. The messaging resonated more strongly, leading to a lower CPC (£0.74) and a higher click-to-lead conversion rate. It just worked.
This shows that the biggest lever you can pull to improve cost efficiency often is not your funnel stage, your ad creative, or your targeting. It is the offer itself. A compelling offer to a hungry market will always outperform a mediocre offer to a 'warm' audience.
The table below breaks down the core performance metrics for all major campaign types in this account. It allows you to explore the data yourself and see how the numbers stack up. You can filter by campaign objective or offer type to isolate the variables and see what really moved the needle.
Campaign Performance Explorer
Use the filters to dissect the performance of different campaign types from the eLearning account dataset. All metrics are calculated from the raw campaign data.
| Campaign Name | Leads | CPL | CPC | CTR | Click-CVR |
|---|
What does this all mean for your own campaigns?
Stepping back from the numbers, there are a few clear takeaways here that apply to almost any paid advertising account, whether you are in eLearning, SaaS, or something else entirely.
First, challenge your assumptions. The idea that retargeting is always the most cost-efficient part of your funnel is a dangerous oversimplification. As we have seen, high competition for small, valuable audiences can drive up click costs to a point where any advantage in conversion rate is lost. You have to run the numbers for your own account.
Second, you must look beyond CPL. It is a useful health metric, but it is not the goal. The goal is to acquire customers profitably. This means you need to understand your funnel economics from end to end: CPL, sales close rate, Customer Acquisition Cost, and Lifetime Value. A more expensive lead that converts to a customer at double the rate is a bargain. To do this properly, you need to track which lead sources are turning into sales, which means getting your CRM and ad platforms talking to each other.
Finally, and perhaps most importantly, the offer is everything. The biggest performance wins do not come from clever targeting hacks or minor tweaks to ad copy. They come from finding a powerful alignment between what you are selling and what a specific audience desperately wants. The 'Data Analytics' campaign worked so well because it hit a nerve. It was the right offer at the right time. Your first job is not to be a better advertiser; it is to be a better student of your market's problems.
This kind of deep-dive analysis is what separates campaigns that just spend money from campaigns that generate real, predictable growth. It is about building systems, not just running ads. It requires a rigorous look at the data, an understanding of the entire customer journey, and a willingness to question the 'best practices' that everyone else takes for granted.
If you are finding that your own campaign performance has hit a plateau or you are struggling to make sense of the numbers, it might be time for a fresh pair of eyes. We often find that a single, structured strategy session is enough to uncover the kinds of opportunities we have discussed here. If you are interested, we offer a free strategy consultation to do just that.
Cite this Research & Data
If referencing this research, data, or strategy in your publication, please use the attribution below.
Lukas Holschuh
Founder, Growth & Advertising Consultant
Great campaigns fail without expertise. Lukas and his team provide the missing strategy, optimizing your entire advertising funnel—from ad creatives and copy to landing page design.
Backed by a proven track record across SaaS, eLearning, and eCommerce, they don't just run ads; they engineer systems that convert. A data-driven partnership focused on tangible revenue growth.