TLDR;
- Most B2B advertisers assume you must pay a premium for 'quality' traffic from developed countries like the US.
- I analysed the full $11k ad spend for a B2B SaaS campaign, and the data shows that broad 'Worldwide' targeting delivered registrations 88 times cheaper than US-only targeting.
- Cheap top-of-funnel traffic isn't necessarily junk. The data proves it can effectively feed a high-converting retargeting system, leading to a profitable full-funnel result.
- This article includes a searchable campaign database, a CPA percentile calculator to see how your costs stack up, and multiple data breakdowns to show what actually worked.
Everyone in B2B advertising will tell you the same thing: get specific. Target decision-makers in high-value countries like the US or UK, pay the premium for that 'quality' traffic, and whatever you do, don't waste money on cheap clicks from the rest of the world. It’s advice that sounds sensible. It’s also, quite possibly, costing you a fortune.
It got me thinking. Does this long-held belief actually hold up when you look at the raw numbers from a real, functioning B2B campaign? Or are we all just paying a massive "quality tax" for no good reason? I decided to have a proper dig into a complete dataset from one of our B2B software clients—a tool for Amazon sellers—to get a straight answer. The question is simple: does broad and cheap actually get beaten by narrow and expensive?
Before we get into it, a bit of honesty. This isn't some massive industry study with data from hundreds of accounts. Frankly, those are often useless because they average everything out to a meaningless number. This is the opposite. It's a forensic look at one specific Meta Ads account, covering $11,013.42 in spend that generated 4,622 software registrations. We're looking at the complete structure: 12 campaigns testing everything from top-of-funnel (TOFU) prospecting in different locations to middle-funnel (MOFU) and bottom-funnel (BOFU) retargeting. This is real data, from the trenches.
So, does targeting expensive countries pay off?
Let's get straight to the biggest question. The campaign strategy involved testing three distinct geographic targeting approaches at the top of the funnel: targeting the US only, targeting a group of 'Developed Countries', and targeting 'Worldwide'. Conventional wisdom dictates the cost per registration should get progressively cheaper, but the quality would plummet. The US should be expensive but deliver the best users, while 'Worldwide' should be cheap but full of duds.
To check this, I grouped the prospecting campaigns by their geographic target and calculated the average cost per registration (CPA) for each. The results weren't just surprising; they were a bit of a bombshell.
Cost Per Registration: Geographic Targeting Comparison
Average cost per software registration from top-of-funnel Meta Ads campaigns, segmented by location targeting strategy. Based on an analysis of $8,648.50 in prospecting spend.
Data source: Analysis of 6 prospecting campaigns from the client's Meta Ads account.
The numbers are clear as day. The US-only campaigns were astronomically expensive, costing $23.32 per registration. The 'Developed Countries' campaigns were better, but at $6.94 they're still not cheap. Then you have the 'Worldwide' campaigns, bringing in registrations for a measly $0.26 each. That's not a small difference. It completely flips the script on where the best value is found. For the cost of acquiring one user in the US, you could have acquired 88 users from the worldwide campaign.
But isn't that just cheap, low-quality traffic?
This is the immediate, and fair, objection. A registration for $0.26 sounds great, but if none of those users ever become paying customers, it's just money down the drain. You're just buying vanity metrics. So, is the cheap 'Worldwide' traffic just rubbish?
This is where looking at the full funnel becomes so important. This account wasn't just running prospecting ads. It had a proper system in place, with MOFU campaigns to retarget website visitors and BOFU campaigns to get trial users to upgrade. The performance of these retargeting campaigns acts as a brilliant quality filter. If the initial traffic from our TOFU campaigns (including the cheap 'Worldwide' ones) was all junk, the retargeting campaigns would have nobody of value to talk to, and their performance would be dreadful.
That's not what happened. The opposite happened. The MOFU campaign, which retargeted all website visitors regardless of where they came from, generated another 1,122 registrations at a stunningly low CPA of just $0.88. This proves that the initial pool of visitors arriving on the site was engaged enough to be converted cheaply on a second touch. If the audience was low-quality, that $0.88 CPA would be impossible. The cheap traffic wasn't just clicking; it was creating a pool of genuinely interested prospects for our mid-funnel ads to mop up.
Full Funnel Performance Architecture
How did the targeting stack up inside the campaigns?
So, going broad on location worked a treat. But what about audience targeting within the campaigns themselves? The dataset gives us a look inside one of the 'Developed Countries' campaigns to see which ad sets pulled their weight. Here, the story gets a bit more traditional.
I broke down the 232 registrations from this campaign by the ad set that generated them. The results show a clear hierarchy of what works. Far and away the best performer was a 1% Lookalike audience based on people who had already completed a registration. This single audience was responsible for nearly 65% of all results. The next best was a Lookalike of actual purchasers. In contrast, broader interest-based audiences like 'Online Retail Interests' and even 'Broad' targeting delivered nothing and were switched off. It seems that while location can be broad, the audience targeting needs to be sharp.
Audience Layering Framework: Lessons from the Data
Layer 1: Core Performance (High-Intent Lookalikes)
Start with Lookalike audiences built from your most valuable conversions. In this account, Lookalikes of 'Completed Registrations' and 'Purchases' drove over 80% of results. This should be your foundational audience.
Layer 2: Niche Interests (Problem-Aware Audiences)
Layer on specific, niche interest audiences that closely match your ideal customer profile. Here, 'Small Business Owners' worked well, contributing 11% of registrations. It's a solid second-tier test.
Layer 3: Broad Interests & Open Targeting (Use With Caution)
Audiences like 'Online Retail Interests' and pure 'Broad' targeting failed to deliver a single registration in this test. While they can work in some accounts, this data suggests you should treat them as highly experimental and be ready to bin them quickly if they don't perform.
The lesson here is a bit more nuanced. You can go wide on geography to let the Meta algorithm find cheap pockets of users, but you must give it a very strong signal about the type of person you're looking for. A Lookalike based on your best customers is the strongest signal you can possibly provide.
How does your CPA stack up?
The overall average CPA for the account was $2.38. But averages, as we know, can be deceiving. When you look at the individual campaign CPAs, the range is enormous, stretching from a rock-bottom $0.21 all the way up to a painful $38.57. This highlights the classic 80/20 rule of advertising: a tiny number of your campaigns will likely be responsible for the vast majority of your efficient results. The job isn't to make every campaign a winner, but to find the winners quickly, double down on them, and kill the losers without mercy.
To put this into perspective, I've taken the CPAs from the 11 campaigns in this account that drove conversions and built a small calculator. You can pop in your own cost per registration and see where you'd rank compared to the performance distribution in this real-world dataset. It is a good way to sense-check if your costs are in the right ballpark, or if there's a major opportunity to optimise.
Where Does Your CPA Rank?
Enter your current Cost Per Registration (CPA) to see how it compares to the performance distribution of campaigns in this B2B SaaS account dataset. The ranks are based on 11 converting campaigns with CPAs ranging from $0.21 to $38.57.
What does this all mean for you?
Pulling all this together, the data paints a very different picture from the one you usually get. The biggest, most actionable insight is that you should seriously question the assumption that B2B requires expensive, tier-1 country targeting from the get-go. This account proves that a strategy of attracting a high volume of cheap, globally-sourced traffic can be incredibly effective—if you have a system to convert them.
The trick isn't just to 'go worldwide' and hope for the best. The strategy that worked here was a combination of:
- Broad Geographic Targeting (TOFU): Using 'Worldwide' to let the algorithm find the cheapest relevant users, drastically lowering the initial cost of traffic.
- Sharp Audience Targeting: Giving the algorithm a strong signal with high-quality Lookalike audiences based on actual paying customers and registrants.
- A Full-Funnel System: Having dedicated MOFU and BOFU campaigns ready to catch and convert the engaged users from the initial prospecting push. Without this, the cheap traffic would likely have gone to waste.
For your own business, this suggests a clear path for testing. Don't just blindly follow the 'experts' who tell you to spend $20 per click on LinkedIn. Have a punt on a lower-budget campaign with broader location settings. But be disciplined. Watch not just the top-of-funnel CPA, but the health of your entire funnel. Are these new, cheaper visitors engaging? Are they signing up for trials? Is your mid-funnel retargeting campaign still performing? If the answer is yes, you may have just unlocked a far more scalable and profitable growth engine than your competitors would ever dare to try.
Of course, every account is different. The numbers and strategies that worked for this Amazon seller tool might not map perfectly onto your business. But the principles—testing assumptions, measuring the full funnel, and focusing on the system, not just a single metric—are universal. It's rarely a single 'hack' that leads to success, but a well-engineered machine where every part is optimised to do its job. Building that machine is where the real work lies.
If you've hit a wall with your current ad strategy or suspect you might be paying that 'quality tax' without seeing the returns, it might be time for a second opinion. We offer a free, no-obligation strategy consultation where we can look at your account and figure out where the real opportunities for growth are hiding.
Cite this Research & Data
If referencing this research, data, or strategy in your publication, please use the attribution below.
Lukas Holschuh
Founder, Growth & Advertising Consultant
Great campaigns fail without expertise. Lukas and his team provide the missing strategy, optimizing your entire advertising funnel—from ad creatives and copy to landing page design.
Backed by a proven track record across SaaS, eLearning, and eCommerce, they don't just run ads; they engineer systems that convert. A data-driven partnership focused on tangible revenue growth.