TLDR;
- Your primary problem isn't your ad creative or targeting; it's your unit economics. An $85 acquisition cost against a $15 monthly LTV is a broken business model issue, not an advertising one.
- You're likely calculating your Lifetime Value (LTV) incorrectly. I've included an LTV calculator below to show you how to properly assess what you can actually afford to spend to acquire a user.
- Your offer is the main bottleneck. For a new app, a hard paywall is a conversion killer. You must switch to a freemium or free trial model to let users experience value before asking them to pay.
- Stop wasting money on retargeting until your top-of-funnel is fixed. You don't have enough qualified traffic to retarget effectively. First, we need to generate cheap, high-quality installs.
- This letter includes a detailed breakdown of the math, an interactive LTV calculator, a visual comparison of different offer strategies, and a step-by-step action plan to restructure your entire acquisition funnel.
Hi there,
Thanks for reaching out. I've had a look at the situation you've described.
Honestly, you're right, that's a tough set of numbers. An $85 customer acquisition cost (CAC) against what you're calling a $15 monthly LTV is completely unsustainable. You're losing $70 on every single user you acquire, and no amount of ad optimisation is going to fix a hole that big. The good news is that the problem probably isn't your ads; it's the system you're pointing them at.
Your funnel is broken at a fundamental, economic level. Before we even touch your Meta or Google campaigns, we need to fix the maths and your offer. Your seed capital is burning because you're trying to force a high-friction offer onto a cold audience, and the economics just don't stack up. Let's walk through how we'd approach getting this sorted.
We'll need to look at your unit economics first...
The first and most glaring issue is the CAC:LTV ratio. You've mentioned a "$15 monthly LTV model," but that's not your LTV. That's one month's revenue. Your Lifetime Value is the total profit you expect to make from a customer over the entire time they use your app. This is the single most important number you need to know, as it dictates what you can afford to spend on acquisition.
If your numbers are wrong here, your entire growth strategy is built on sand. You stop looking for cheap leads and start asking, "How much can I profitably pay for a great customer?" Let's run the numbers properly.
The calculation is pretty straightforward:
LTV = (Average Revenue Per User (ARPU) * Gross Margin %) / Monthly Churn Rate
Let's plug in some realistic assumptions for an early-stage app. Let's say your average subscription is $15/month (your ARPU). Your gross margin is probably high for software, say 85%. The big variable is churn—the percentage of users who cancel each month. For a new app, churn can be high, let's be conservative and say it's 20% per month.
So, your LTV would be: ($15 * 0.85) / 0.20 = $12.75 / 0.20 = $63.75
This is a more realistic LTV. It's still lower than your $85 CAC, which shows we're still deep in the red. But now we have a real number to work with. A healthy business model aims for an LTV to CAC ratio of at least 3:1. This means, with an LTV of $63.75, your target CAC should be around $21, not $85. You are overspending by about 4x.
This is the math that unlocks intelligent growth. Suddenly, the goal isn't just to lower CAC, but to improve the variables that increase LTV: increasing ARPU (e.g., with tiered plans) or, more importantly, decreasing churn by making the product stickier.
App & SaaS Lifetime Value Calculator
Adjust the sliders to model your LTV based on your business metrics and determine a sustainable target Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC).
I'd say you need to bin the 'Subscribe Now' offer...
With the economics sorted, we hit the second, even bigger problem: your offer. Asking a new user to pay for an unknown language app upfront is like asking someone to marry you on a first date. It's a massive commitment with no proven value. This is the single biggest reason your CAC is $85. You're paying a premium to find the 0.01% of people willing to take that risk.
You're in the software game. Your unfair advantage is the ability to let the product sell itself. The gold standard here is a free trial or a freemium plan. No card details, no friction. Let them install the app, match with a language partner, have a conversation, and feel the moment of clarity. Once they've experienced that value, the conversion to a paid plan becomes a natural next step, not a huge hurdle.
I've seen this time and again. I've helped software clients massively increase trials just by removing the credit card requirement upfront. When we ran campaigns for app growth, driving over 45,000 signups at under £2 each across Meta, TikTok, Apple Ads, and Google Ads, the lead volume exploded. Even though not everyone converts, the final CAC for a paying customer plummets because the top of your funnel is suddenly wider.
Your offer’s only job is to deliver undeniable value. For you, that's a successful language exchange. Solve that small, real problem for free, and you'll earn the right to ask for their money. We're not trying to generate sales directly from an ad; we're trying to generate Product Qualified Users who are already convinced because the app has already worked for them.
The difference this makes to your funnel is night and day. Look at the math below. By shifting from a direct-to-paid model to a freemium or trial model, you dramatically increase your top-of-funnel conversion rate, which slashes your cost per install and, ultimately, your cost per paying subscriber.
The Math of Your App's Offer
Assuming a monthly ad spend of £5,000 at an average Cost Per Click (CPC) of £1.25, generating 4,000 clicks to your app store page:
(DIRECT TO PAID)
(10% Upgrade Rate)
(40% Upgrade Rate)
By switching from a high-friction paywall to a value-first free trial, your effective acquisition cost can drop by over 80%, finally aligning with your target CAC.
You probably should restructure your campaigns for installs, not sales...
Once you have a low-friction offer (freemium or a free trial), your entire advertising strategy needs to change. You are no longer trying to find the rare person willing to pay upfront. Your new job is to acquire as many qualified trial users or free installs as cheaply as possible.
This means your campaign objective on Meta and Google should be set to app installs or registrations, not purchases. You are paying the platform to find people likely to download and try an app, which is a much larger and cheaper audience to reach than those ready to subscribe immediately. In our app growth campaigns, we've driven over 45,000 signups at under £2 each across Meta, TikTok, Apple Ads, and Google Ads. One of our software clients also secured 3,543 users at just £0.96 per user on Google Ads. This is the world you should be in, not the $85 trap you're in now.
Here’s how you should approach your targeting now:
- Forget Broad Awareness: You might be tempted to run reach campaigns. Don't. You're just paying the platform to find the cheapest, lowest-quality users who will never convert. As I often mention to clients, awareness is a byproduct of having a great product that solves a real problem, not a prerequisite for making a sale. You need conversions, even if they are free installs to start with.
- Define the Nightmare: Your customer's pain isn't wanting to learn a language. It's trying an app for six months and still not holding a basic conversation, or moving abroad for work and feeling terrified of not communicating. Your ad copy needs to speak directly to this frustration. Use a Before-After-Bridge framework. Before: stuck learning words without real conversations. After: imagining chatting confidently with a native speaker. Bridge: an app that connects you instantly.
- Target Intent, Not Demographics: On Google, this means targeting keywords that show intent, like alternative apps or language exchange partners. On Meta, instead of targeting broad interests like travel, target niche communities, followers of specific language influencers, or users interested in competitor apps.
You need to pre-qualify your audience with your messaging. Your ads should act as a filter, attracting only those who feel the specific pain your app solves. This is how you drive down the cost per install and ensure the users you get are the ones most likely to eventually upgrade.
You'll need to rethink your entire funnel, including retargeting...
You mentioned retargeting in your title, but right now, it's a waste of money for you. You can't effectively retarget an audience that doesn't exist. Your top-of-funnel is so narrow and expensive that you don't have a pool of qualified warm users to speak to.
Once you've fixed the offer and are driving hundreds or thousands of cheap installs, then we can build a proper funnel. The structure is logical and follows the user's journey. It's not just one retargeting audience; it's a sequence.
The App Acquisition Funnel
Here’s the audience priority I would set up for you on Meta, once you're driving installs:
Top of Funnel - Acquisition:
- Your goal here is cheap, quality installs.
- Audiences: Test detailed targeting (interests in competitors, language learning influencers) and lookalike audiences based on your best future customers (once you have enough data). Start with a lookalike of all installs, then move to a lookalike of trial starters, and finally a lookalike of paying subscribers.
Middle of Funnel - Activation:
- Goal: Get people who installed the app but haven't been active or started a trial to come back and engage.
- Audience: People who installed the app in the last 30 days but haven't opened it in the last 7, or haven't completed a primary action like their first chat.
- Message: Remind them of the value. Show testimonials or user-generated content of successful exchanges.
Bottom of Funnel - Monetisation:
- Goal: Convert active free users or trial users into paying subscribers.
- Audience: Users whose free trial is about to expire, or highly active freemium users who are hitting the limits of their free plan.
- Message: This is where you sell. Offer a limited-time discount for upgrading to keep conversations going.
This layered approach allows you to speak to users with the right message at the right time. But it only works if the top of your funnel is a flood, not a trickle. Fix the offer, and you fix the entire system.
I've detailed my main recommendations for you below:
App Acquisition Action Blueprint
This is the prioritised sequence of actions to take your acquisition model from unprofitable to scalable.
| Priority | Problem Area | Diagnostic Action Item | Expected Impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Immediate | Unit Economics | Recalculate your true LTV based on realistic churn. Establish a new target CAC at a 3:1 LTV:CAC ratio. | A realistic budget for growth |
| 2. Critical | The Offer | Bin the direct-to-paid model. Implement a frictionless free trial or a freemium plan immediately. | -80% Cost Per Paying User |
| 3. High | Ad Campaign Structure | Change campaign objectives on all platforms to "App Installs" or "Registrations". Rewrite ad copy to focus on user pain points. | Dramatically lower Cost Per Install |
| 4. Medium | Targeting | Pause broad audiences. Focus on high-intent keywords (Google) and competitor/niche community interests (Meta). | Higher quality installs |
| 5. Future | Retargeting Funnel | Once you have 1,000+ new installs, build out MoFu and BoFu campaigns to activate and convert your new user base. | Increased LTV & conversion rate |
You've built businesses before, so you know that growth is a systems problem. Right now, your system is clogged at the source. It's not about finding a magic audience or a winning ad; it's about re-architecting your entire acquisition model so it's built for scale.
This is a lot to take on, especially when you're also trying to run the business. Getting this funnel right requires expertise, not just in running ads, but in understanding the entire customer journey—from the first impression of an ad to the psychology of the landing page and the triggers inside the app.
If you'd like a second pair of eyes to go over your setup in more detail and map out a precise, actionable growth plan, we offer a free initial consultation. We can review your strategy and accounts together, which usually gives founders a huge amount of clarity on what to do next.
Regards,
Lukas Holschuh
Cite this Q&A Guide
If referencing this research, data, or strategy in your publication, please use the attribution below.
Lukas Holschuh
Founder, Growth & Advertising Consultant
Great campaigns fail without expertise. Lukas and his team provide the missing strategy, optimizing your entire advertising funnel—from ad creatives and copy to landing page design.
Backed by a proven track record across SaaS, eLearning, and eCommerce, they don't just run ads; they engineer systems that convert. A data-driven partnership focused on tangible revenue growth.