What are the core issues here?
- Your core problem isn't your ads; it's a major mismatch between your Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC) of $85 and what you think is your Lifetime Value (LTV).
- The $15/month figure you mentioned isn't your LTV; it's your Average Revenue Per Account (ARPA). I'll show you how to calculate your true LTV, which will completely change what you can afford to spend on ads.
- The number one reason campaigns fail is a weak offer. "Sign up for my app" isn't an offer. We need to build a low-friction, high-value proposition that gets users to an "aha!" moment quickly.
- Forget LinkedIn for this. Your focus should be on Meta and Google, but your campaign objectives are likely wrong. You're probably paying platforms to find you non-customers. We'll fix that.
- This letter includes an interactive calculator to help you determine your real LTV and allowable acquisition costs, which is the first step to turning this around.
Hi there,
Thanks for reaching out. I've had a look at the situation you've described, and fair play for being so direct about the numbers. It sounds like a tough spot to be in, and that tough feeling is something I've seen many founders go through before they find a breakthrough.
I'm happy to give you some initial thoughts. Honestly, from what you've said, this isn't an ad tweaking problem. An $85 CAC against a $15/month price point is a business-level fire that needs putting out, not just a campaign that needs a new headline. Simply auditing your LinkedIn ads would be like rearranging the deckchairs on the Titanic.
The good news is that the problem is almost certainly systemic, which means we can fix it with a better system. We need to work backwards from your business model, fix the maths, re-engineer your offer, and only then rebuild the ad strategy on that solid foundation. Let's get into it.
Why are my unit economics currently broken?
Let's be blunt. You don't have an $85 CAC problem. You have a unit economics problem, rooted in a misunderstanding of what Customer Lifetime Value (LTV) actually is. You said your LTV model is "$15 monthly". That's not your LTV. That's your Average Revenue Per Account (ARPA), or simply your monthly price.
LTV is the total profit you can expect to make from a single customer over the entire duration of their relationship with you. Knowing this number is the only way to determine how much you can actually afford to spend to acquire a customer (your CAC). Without it, you're flying blind and burning cash at an alarming rate.
The real question isn't "How low can my CAC go?" but "How high a CAC can I afford to acquire a great customer?" The answer is found by calculating LTV correctly.
Below is the basic formula we use:
LTV = (Average Revenue Per Account (ARPA) * Gross Margin %) / Monthly Churn Rate %
Let's break that down with some realistic numbers for an early-stage app:
- ARPA: This is your $15/month.
- Gross Margin %: This is your profit margin after accounting for costs directly related to serving that user (e.g., server costs, API calls, customer support for that user). For a software app, this is often quite high. Let's be generous and say it's 85%.
- Monthly Churn Rate: This is the percentage of paying subscribers you lose each month. This is the silent killer of subscription businesses. For a new app finding its feet, a 10% monthly churn is not uncommon (though you'd want to get this down to 3-5% long-term).
Now, let's do the calculation with these assumptions:
LTV = ($15 * 0.85) / 0.10
LTV = $12.75 / 0.10
LTV = $127.50
So, your actual LTV isn't $15. It's closer to $127.50. This is the real value of a new subscriber.
Now we have a target. A healthy, sustainable business model typically aims for an LTV to CAC ratio of at least 3:1. This means your LTV should be at least three times your CAC. This gives you room for operational costs, salaries, and profit.
Allowable CAC = LTV / 3
Allowable CAC = $127.50 / 3 = $42.50
Suddenly, the picture is different. Your current CAC of $85 is still double what it should be, but the goal of $42.50 is far more achievable than trying to get a paying subscriber for less than $15. The problem is no longer impossible; it's just an optimisation challenge. You've been trying to hit a target you didn't even know existed.
To make this tangible for you, I've built a small calculator. Play around with the numbers, especially the churn rate. You'll see how even a small improvement in customer retention dramatically increases your LTV and, therefore, the budget you have to acquire new users.
LTV & Allowable CAC Calculator
Adjust the sliders to model your app's unit economics and find your true target acquisition cost.
How do I fix an offer that isn't converting?
Now that we know your target CAC is around $42, we need a plan to get there. The single most powerful adjustment you can make to slash your CAC isn't ad copy or audience targeting; it's your offer.
From my experience running campaigns for hundreds of businesses, the number one reason they fail is a weak offer. Founders spend years building the perfect product, then go to market with a call to action like "Sign up" or "Buy now". This is high-friction and low-value. You're asking for a commitment before you've provided any real, tangible value.
For an app like yours, the goal is to get a user to their "aha!" moment as fast as possible. That's the moment they experience the core value of your app and think, "Wow, this is actually great." For a language exchange app, that moment is probably their first successful, non-awkward conversation with a native speaker. Your entire advertising funnel should be engineered to deliver that moment.
The "Request a Demo" button is the most arrogant CTA in B2B. Its B2C equivalent is "Download our App". It presumes the user cares enough to go through the entire process of downloading, creating an account, and figuring out your UI on their own. Most won't.
You need to bundle your expertise into a tool or an experience that provides instant value. Below are a few ideas for stronger, lower-friction offers:
- The "First Conversation" Guarantee: Instead of selling an app, sell a result. "Find your first language partner and have a 10-minute conversation in the next 7 days, or your first month is free." This reframes the value proposition entirely.
- An Interactive "Matching" Quiz: Before asking them to download anything, create a simple quiz on a landing page. "What language do you want to learn?", "What are your interests?", "What's your current level?". At the end, you show them profiles of 3 perfect language partners already on your platform. The call to action is then "Message [Name] now for free". You deliver value before you ask for the sign-up.
- A Founder's Club Lifetime Deal (LTD): I've seen this work wonders for early-stage software. You offer the first 100 or 500 users a lifetime subscription for a one-time fee (e.g., $99). This does two things: it generates a huge amount of upfront cash and creates a cohort of highly committed early adopters who will give you invaluable feedback. We ran a campaign like this for a software client that brought in $30k in sales very quickly. It's a great way to kickstart your user base.
Let's look at the maths. A simple shift in offer can have a dramatic effect on conversion rates, which directly impacts your CAC. If your ads are getting a click-through rate of 1% and your landing page is converting at 2% (which is generous for a direct "sign up" offer), your cost per signup is high. A stronger offer could easily double or triple that landing page conversion rate.
The Maths of a Better Offer
Assuming a monthly ad spend of £5,000 at an average Cost Per Click (CPC) of £2.50 (2,000 clicks/month):
By shifting from a generic "sign up" offer to a high-value, outcome-focused one, your Cost Per Subscriber can drop by over 80% without spending a penny more on ads.
Which ad platform and strategy should I actually be using?
Once you have a compelling offer, we can talk about ads. You mentioned a LinkedIn ads audit in your title, but you're running on Meta and Google. Let's clear this up first: for a B2C language exchange app, LinkedIn is almost certainly the wrong place to be. It's expensive, the mindset of users is professional, and the targeting isn't built for your use case. Stick with Meta and Google for now. They are the right platforms.
The problem is likely how you're using them. The following is a very common and expensive mistake I see founders make:
When you set up a campaign on Meta and choose an objective like "Reach" or "Brand Awareness", you are explicitly telling the algorithm: "Find me the cheapest possible eyeballs, regardless of their quality or intent." The algorithm does exactly that. It serves your ads to people inside your target audience who are least likely to click, least likely to engage, and absolutely least likely to ever subscribe. Why? Because their attention is cheap. You are paying to find the worst possible prospects.
You must switch your campaign objective to "Conversions" or "Sales". For an app, this would likely be optimising for an "App Install" or, even better, a "Subscription" event if you have your in-app events configured correctly. This tells the algorithm to find people who have a history of doing that specific action. It will be more expensive per impression and per click, but your cost per actual subscriber will plummet because the traffic quality is infinitely higher.
Next, let's talk targeting. Your Ideal Customer Profile (ICP) is not a demographic. It's not "people aged 25-40 interested in travel". That's useless. Your ICP is a problem state. It's the person who feels embarrassed trying to order a coffee on holiday. It's the expat who feels lonely and isolated in a new country. It's the professional who needs to learn business Spanish to close a deal.
Your ad targeting and copy must speak to that specific pain. Below is how I'd prioritise audiences on Meta for a new account:
- Detailed Targeting (Interests): Start here. Don't just target "Spanish Language". That's too broad. Get specific.
- Competitor Audiences: Target users interested in Duolingo, Babbel, Rosetta Stone, Memrise. These people have already proven they are willing to use an app to learn a language.
- Problem/Solution-Aware Audiences: Target interests like "Language exchange", "Tandem learning", "Expat in [Your Country]".
- Niche-Related Interests: Target followers of popular language learning influencers, polyglot bloggers, or travel pages that focus on cultural immersion.
- Lookalike Audiences: Once you get your first 100+ subscribers (even from the LTD offer), create a Lookalike audience. This tells Meta "go find me more people who look exactly like my best customers". This is often where scaling happens. You can create lookalikes of website visitors, app installers, and eventually, paying subscribers. The closer the source audience is to the final conversion, the better the lookalike will be.
- Retargeting Audiences: Not everyone will sign up on the first visit. You need to set up campaigns to retarget people who visited your landing page, watched your ad videos, or installed the app but didn't subscribe. Show them testimonials, different features, or a special welcome back offer.
I've mapped out what a basic funnel structure using these audience types looks like below. You need separate campaigns talking to people at each stage of awareness.
User Acquisition Funnel Architecture
How do I write ad copy that actually gets attention?
Finally, your ads themselves need to communicate your new, stronger offer by speaking directly to the nightmare your ICP is facing. Don't sell the app; sell the transformation.
We use a simple copywriting framework for this called Before-After-Bridge.
- Before: Describe their current world of pain. "Staring at verb conjugation charts? Feeling your stomach drop when a local asks you for directions? Language learning feels lonely and impossible."
- After: Paint a picture of the dream outcome. "Imagine laughing with a new friend from Madrid over video call. Effortlessly ordering street food in Tokyo. Connecting with people, not just memorising words."
- Bridge: Introduce your app as the clear, simple path from Before to After. "Our app is the bridge. We connect you with native speakers who share your interests, so you can start having real conversations from day one. Find your first partner in the next 5 minutes."
For creative, bin the generic app mockups and stock photos. The most effective creative we've seen for software and app clients, especially in the early stages, is User-Generated Content (UGC). Get your first few users to record short, authentic videos of themselves using the app and talking about their experience. A shaky, vertical phone video of a real user having a real conversation is a thousand times more persuasive than a polished corporate ad. It provides social proof and feels genuine.
This whole system—correct maths, a strong offer, the right ad strategy, and compelling creative—works together. Fixing one part in isolation won't work. You need to fix the entire machine.
I've detailed my main recommendations for you below:
Funnel Rebuild & Action Blueprint
A prioritised matrix to diagnose and fix the core failure points in your current user acquisition funnel.
| Priority | Primary Failure Point | Diagnostic Action Item | Expected Impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Unit Economics | Miscalculating LTV, leading to an impossible CAC target. | Calculate true LTV using the (ARPA * Margin) / Churn formula. Establish a realistic, allowable CAC (target: ~$42.50). | Sets a realistic target |
| 2. The Offer | High-friction, low-value "Sign up" CTA is killing conversion rates. | Design and test a low-friction, high-value offer (e.g., "First Conversation Guarantee" or a Lifetime Deal). Build a new landing page around it. | -50-80% CAC Reduction |
| 3. Ad Strategy | Using wrong campaign objectives and overly broad targeting. | Restructure campaigns on Meta/Google to optimise for Conversions (App Installs/Subscriptions). Implement prioritised audience testing (Competitors > Lookalikes > Retargeting). | Higher quality traffic |
| 4. Creative & Messaging | Generic ads that don't speak to user pain points. | Rewrite ad copy using the Before-After-Bridge framework. Source authentic UGC-style video creative from early users. | +50% Click-Through Rate |
This is a lot to tackle, especially when you're also trying to build a product and run a business. Great campaigns fail without expertise, and what you need is more than just an ad manager; you need a system that converts.
If you'd like to go through this in more detail and have us apply our experience from scaling other software apps to your specific situation, we offer a free, no-obligation initial consultation. We can review your current setup together and map out a more detailed strategy.
Regards,
Team @ Lukas Holschuh
Cite this Q&A Guide
If referencing this research, data, or strategy in your publication, please use the attribution below.
Lukas Holschuh
Founder, Growth & Advertising Consultant
Great campaigns fail without expertise. Lukas and his team provide the missing strategy, optimizing your entire advertising funnel—from ad creatives and copy to landing page design.
Backed by a proven track record across SaaS, eLearning, and eCommerce, they don't just run ads; they engineer systems that convert. A data-driven partnership focused on tangible revenue growth.