TLDR;
- Hiring an agency right now is probably a mistake. Your ads failed because your offer and sales funnel are likely broken, not just because you are inexperienced with running ads. No agency can fix a fundamental offer problem.
- Stop thinking about your customer as a generic demographic ("people who like writing"). You need to define them by their specific, urgent nightmare pain point (such as the fear of dying with an unpublished novel). This forms the foundation for creating ads that actually work.
- Your current offer—likely a direct "buy our workshop" pitch—is too high-friction for cold traffic. You need to build a sandbox offer: a free, high-value tool or mini-course that solves a small problem for them upfront to earn their trust.
- You must understand your numbers before spending another penny. I have included a guide on calculating your Customer Lifetime Value (LTV) to figure out what you can actually afford to pay for a customer (your allowable Customer Acquisition Cost).
- This letter contains a few frameworks to help you, including a targeting layering model and an interactive calculator to simulate how fixing your funnel will dramatically lower your acquisition costs.
Hi there,
Thanks for reaching out. I am happy to give you some initial thoughts and guidance on your situation.
It is a tough spot to be in—you have launched, you know you have something valuable, but getting those first paying customers feels like pushing a boulder uphill. Burning through a budget with little to show for it is a common story, and honestly, it is a situation we see all the time. The immediate reaction is often to look for an expert or an agency to take over the ads. But from my experience, that is usually jumping the gun and can lead to you burning cash even faster, just with a professional at the controls.
The problem rarely starts with the ads themselves. Ads are just an amplifier. They amplify what is already working, or they amplify what is broken. Your early results suggest it is the latter. Before you think about hiring anyone or spending more on campaigns, we need to take a step back and look at the whole system.
We will need to look at why your ads are actually failing...
You mentioned a terrible ROI after running your own campaigns. That does not surprise me. Most founders who are experts in their own field—like creative writing—are not expected to be experts in the complex mechanics of paid acquisition. But the issue is not that you picked the wrong button in Ads Manager. The issue is almost certainly a disconnect in your funnel.
Early in my career, I had clients with what I thought were great products. I would set up what were technically brilliant campaigns—great targeting, sharp copy, everything by the book. We would get loads of clicks, high click-through rates, all the metrics that look good on a report. But no sales. The money just vanished. It drove me mad until I realised the problem was not on my end. I could send the most qualified traffic in the world to a client's website, but if the landing page was confusing, if the offer was not compelling, or if the messaging on the page had nothing to do with the ad they just clicked, the whole thing would fall apart. The campaign was doomed before it even started.
That is when I realised we could not just run ads. We had to engineer the entire system, from the ad creative right through to the final conversion. This is likely where things are going wrong for you. You are sending people to a platform that you are passionate about, but the journey you are asking them to take is probably flawed.
A common mistake at this stage is to run awareness campaigns. You set your objective to reach or brand awareness on a platform like Meta, thinking you need to get your name out there. Here is the harsh truth: you are actively paying the platform to find the worst possible audience for your product. You have given it a command to find the most eyeballs for the least money. The algorithm does exactly that, showing your ads to people who are cheap to reach because they never click, engage, or buy anything. Their attention is worthless to you. For a startup, awareness is a byproduct of making sales and solving problems, not a prerequisite for it. You need to be running campaigns optimised for actual conversions—sign-ups, leads, purchases—from day one.
But even with a conversion objective, if the underlying strategy is wrong, you will just pay a lot more for zero results. So, let us fix the strategy first.
I would say you need to define your customer by their pain, not their hobby...
Forget the generic customer profile. Aspiring writers aged 25-45 who like Stephen King and follow literary journals is a useless starting point for targeting. It tells you nothing of value and leads to the kind of generic ads that get ignored because they speak to no one in particular.
To stop burning cash, you have to define your customer by their pain. Their specific, urgent, expensive nightmare. Your Ideal Customer Profile (ICP) is not a person; it is a problem state. You need to become an obsessive expert in that problem.
Let us brainstorm this for a creative writing platform. Who are you really for?
- The Aspiring Novelist? Their nightmare is not wanting to write a book. Their nightmare is the crushing fear of dying with a half-finished manuscript buried on their hard drive. It is the shame of telling friends and family for years that they are working on a novel with nothing to show for it. It is the terror of getting another rejection letter and believing they will never be good enough.
- The Burnt-Out Professional? Maybe you are targeting people in corporate jobs who used to be creative. Their nightmare is looking at their calendar filled with soul-crushing meetings and realising they have not written a single creative sentence in ten years. Their pain is the feeling that a core part of their identity has withered away, and they are desperate to get it back before it is gone for good.
- The Hobbyist Blogger? Their nightmare is publishing a post they poured their heart into and seeing two views in their analytics, one of which was them. Their pain is screaming into the void, feeling invisible and wondering why their stories do not connect with anyone.
See the difference? We are not talking about a hobby anymore. We are talking about deep-seated professional and emotional fears. When you understand this, you can stop targeting broad interests and start targeting the symptoms of their pain.
Where do these people go to solve their problems? The aspiring novelist with rejection-letter anxiety is probably in a group called Query Letter Hell. They might follow literary agents on Twitter or listen to podcasts like The Shit No One Tells You About Writing. The burnt-out professional might be searching for how to start a creative hobby again.
This intelligence is the blueprint for your entire targeting strategy. Before you spend another pound, you need to do this work. The figure below shows how you can structure this thinking into layers for your ad campaigns. You start broad, then you add layers of qualification to make sure you are talking to the right person.
Targeting Layering Framework: Finding Your Writer
Layer 1: The Broad Canvas (Demographic Boundary)
This is your starting point. For example: Age 25-55 AND Location (e.g., UK, US, Canada) AND Language (English).
Layer 2: The Writer's Identity (Psychographics & Interests)
Now we narrow. Target people who follow specific, niche authors (not just Stephen King, think more like Brandon Sanderson or N.K. Jemisin) AND are members of writing-focused Facebook Groups (e.g., '20BooksTo50k'). This shows they are active, not just passive fans.
Layer 3: The Pain Signal (Behaviour & Intent)
This is the standout layer. Target people who have recently engaged with ads for writing software (e.g., Scrivener, ProWritingAid) OR have visited websites of major writing competitions. This is a strong signal they are actively trying to solve their writing problem right now.
Once you have this level of clarity, your ad copy writes itself. Instead of "Become a better writer," your ad can say, "Is your first chapter failing to hook agents? Our First-Chapter-Fix workshop will show you the three mistakes 99% of new novelists make." You are speaking directly to their pain. That is how you get someone to stop scrolling and click.
You probably should rethink your offer...
This brings us to the most common point of failure for early-stage businesses: the offer itself. Asking a cold prospect, who has never heard of you, to pull out their credit card and pay for a workshop is a huge ask. It is a high-friction, low-trust proposition. In B2B marketing, this resembles the arrogance of the request a demo button. For you, it is the buy our workshop button. It presumes they should immediately trust you with their time and money.
Why should they? There are thousands of free writing resources on YouTube, countless blogs, and established platforms like MasterClass. Your offer's only job is to break through that noise by delivering an undeniable moment of value—an aha moment—that makes the prospect sell themselves on your expertise.
You need to stop selling the workshop and start solving a small, painful problem for free. You need to create a sandbox offer. This is an asset, tool, or piece of content that gives them an immediate win. For your business, this could be:
- An Interactive Plot Hole Detector: A simple quiz where they answer 10 questions about their story, and it provides an instant report highlighting potential structural weaknesses.
- A Free 5-Day First Draft Email Course: A short, automated email series that guides them through a structured process to get a story idea onto the page.
- A Writer's Block Buster Tool: A webpage with a curated set of high-concept writing prompts they can generate, far better than the generic ones found elsewhere.
This is not just a lead magnet; it is a product sample. It demonstrates your expertise. It builds trust. It gets their email address, so you can nurture the relationship. You earn the right to ask for the sale later. The goal is to create Product Qualified Leads (PQLs)—people who have already experienced the value of what you do, even in a small way.
The economic impact of this shift is massive. Let us run the numbers. Imagine you have a tiny budget of £1,000 to get started, and your average Cost Per Click (CPC) is £2.00. That gives you 500 clicks to work with.
The Math of a Better Offer
Assuming a monthly ad budget of £1,000 at an average Cost Per Click (CPC) of £2.00 (500 clicks/month):
By introducing a free, high-value offer, you triple your customer volume and slash your acquisition cost by 67%, all while building an email list of other potential customers to nurture.
In the first scenario, you send cold traffic directly to a sales page. Conversion rates for this are typically abysmal for a new brand, maybe 0.2% if you are lucky. With 500 clicks, that gets you exactly one customer at a cost of £1,000. That is not a business; it is a very expensive hobby.
In the second scenario, you send that same traffic to a landing page for your free Plot Hole Detector tool. Because it is free and high-value, your conversion rate to a lead (an email sign-up) is much higher, let us say 15%. Suddenly, those 500 clicks generate 75 leads, at a Cost Per Lead of £13.33. You have not made any money yet, but you have acquired 75 assets.
Now, through an automated email sequence, you nurture those 75 leads. You provide more value, share testimonials, and then you offer them your paid workshop. Let us say a conservative 4% of those leads convert to paying customers. That is 3 customers. Your total ad spend was still £1,000, so your effective Cost Per Paying Customer is now £333. You have just tripled your customer acquisition for the same budget, and you still have 72 other warm leads on your email list you can sell to in the future.
This is how you build a sustainable acquisition machine. You stop trying to force a sale on day one and start building a relationship by providing value.
You will need to understand the numbers before you spend another penny...
This all leads to the most important question in advertising, which is not how low can my Cost Per Lead go, but how high a customer acquisition cost can I actually afford. Without knowing this number, you are flying blind. The answer lies in your Customer Lifetime Value (LTV).
For a workshop platform, the calculation is a bit different from a typical SaaS subscription, but the principle is the same. We need to figure out what a customer is worth to you over their entire relationship with your business.
Let us build a simple model:
- Average Workshop Price (AWP): The price of your core workshop. Let us say it is £150.
- Average Repeat Purchases (ARP): How many workshops does the average customer buy over their lifetime? To start, let us be conservative and say 1.2 (meaning 1 in 5 customers comes back to buy a second one).
- Gross Margin %: Your profit margin after any direct costs (e.g., instructor fees, platform costs). Let us assume it is high, say 80%.
Now, the calculation for LTV is straightforward:
LTV = AWP * ARP * Gross Margin %
LTV = £150 * 1.2 * 0.80 = £144
So, in this hypothetical scenario, each customer you acquire is worth £144 in gross margin to your business. This number is your guiding metric.
A healthy, sustainable business model typically aims for a 3:1 LTV to Customer Acquisition Cost (CAC) ratio. This means for every £3 of value a customer brings in, you can afford to spend £1 to acquire them.
Allowable CAC = LTV / 3
Allowable CAC = £144 / 3 = £48
This is your baseline truth. You can afford to spend up to £48 to acquire a single paying customer and still have a healthy, scalable business. Suddenly, that £1,000 CPA from our first scenario looks disastrous, and even the £333 CPA from our improved funnel needs work. But now you have a concrete target. Your entire marketing system must be engineered to acquire customers for £48 or less.
This math unlocks intelligent growth. It frees you from the tyranny of chasing cheap clicks or low CPLs and focuses you on the only metric that matters: profitable customer acquisition. To make this tangible, I have built a small simulator below. You can see how tweaking the core factors of your funnel—the offer, the copy, the follow-up—impacts your final customer acquisition cost.
Funnel Optimisation & CPA Simulator
Select your baseline scenario and toggle the optimisation factors to see the projected impact on your customer acquisition cost.
So, should you hire an agency?
Now we can finally answer your original question. And my honest advice is: no, not yet.
Hiring an agency right now would be a mistake. A good agency will either turn you down because you are too early stage and do not have a proven offer (product-market fit), or a lower quality agency will happily take your money, run the same kind of ads you did, and get you the same poor results while charging you a hefty fee for the privilege.
An agency is a scaling tool, not a magic wand. They are for when you have a funnel that is already working and converting customers at a profitable CAC, and you need the expertise and manpower to pour fuel on the fire. You do not have a fire yet; you are still trying to get the kindling to catch.
Your immediate priority is not finding someone to manage your ads. It is to fix the foundational pillars of your acquisition strategy: your ICP definition, your offer, and your funnel. This is strategic work that you, as a co-founder, need to be deeply involved in.
Fractional help could be a good option, but only if you find the right kind of person. You do not need a media buyer who lives in Ads Manager. You need a growth strategist, someone with full-funnel experience who can help you architect this entire system from the ground up. Someone who will challenge your assumptions about your offer and your customer, help you build the sandbox asset, write the landing page copy, and set up the measurement to prove it is working.
This is exactly the kind of work we do. We do not just run ads; we engineer the systems that make ads profitable. I have seen this exact situation play out many times, especially in the eLearning and course space. We have helped clients generate $115k in course sales or achieve a 447% ROAS in a single week, but those results were only possible because we first worked with them to nail these fundamentals. Without a solid foundation, you are just building on sand.
I have put together a summary of the steps I would recommend you take, in order of priority. This is your blueprint for the next 3-6 months.
Acquisition Funnel Action Blueprint
A prioritised plan to move from burning cash to building a predictable customer acquisition engine.
| Phase | Core Problem | Action Item | Expected Impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Foundation | Generic targeting and a high-friction offer. | Define your ICP by their nightmare pain point. Create a high-value sandbox offer (free tool, mini-course) that solves a small piece of that pain. | Clarity on who to target & what to say. |
| 2. Funnel Build | Website is not built to convert cold traffic. | Build a dedicated landing page for your sandbox offer. Use Problem-Agitate-Solve copy. Set up an automated email nurture sequence for new leads. | -80% Cost Per Lead |
| 3. Measurement | Flying blind on unit economics and profitability. | Calculate your Customer LTV and establish your true allowable CAC based on a 3:1 ratio. Install tracking pixels properly. | Ability to make data-driven decisions. |
| 4. Validation | Trying to scale a broken system. | Run small-budget (£20-£50/day) conversion campaigns to the sandbox offer. Test audiences based on your ICP research. Aim for 100+ leads, not 10 customers. | Validate the funnel is working before scaling spend. |
This might feel like a lot to take on, and that is because it is. Building a proper acquisition engine is complex. Getting these foundational pieces wrong is the primary reason most startups fail to get traction with paid ads. This is where expert guidance can make a significant difference—not just in pushing buttons in Ads Manager, but in architecting the whole strategy that ensures those buttons actually lead to profitable growth.
If you would like to go through this in more detail for your specific platform and map out a clear path forward, we offer a free, no-obligation initial consultation. We can review what you have done so far and give you some concrete, actionable advice you can take away and implement immediately.
Regards,
Team @ Lukas Holschuh
Cite this Q&A Guide
If referencing this research, data, or strategy in your publication, please use the attribution below.
Lukas Holschuh
Founder, Growth & Advertising Consultant
Great campaigns fail without expertise. Lukas and his team provide the missing strategy, optimizing your entire advertising funnel—from ad creatives and copy to landing page design.
Backed by a proven track record across SaaS, eLearning, and eCommerce, they don't just run ads; they engineer systems that convert. A data-driven partnership focused on tangible revenue growth.