You’re running two types of campaigns for the same product—one driving app installs, the other driving web sign-ups. You look at the numbers and see a massive gap. The app install campaign boasts a 49% conversion rate, while your web campaigns are hovering around 20-30%. The immediate conclusion is that the app campaign is a runaway success and the web campaigns are lagging. It seems obvious: the app install journey is just simpler, lower friction, so it converts better. Fair play, but that's a surface-level answer, and it can lead you to make some pretty dodgy decisions about where to put your budget.
So, what's really causing this massive variance in conversion rates? Is one funnel genuinely better than the other? I decided to dig into the data from a single, complete Google Ads account we managed for ScoutIQ, a book-scanning app. By looking at the raw performance across their different campaign types, we can move past simple assumptions and get to the bottom of what these metrics are actually telling us. This isn't an industry-wide benchmark study; it's a thorough look at one account, which is often more useful as it lets us compare apples with apples, or so you'd think.
But what are we actually measuring?
Before we even get into the weeds of campaign performance, we have to be completely honest about what a conversion actually means in these two different scenarios. They are not the same thing. Not even close. For the app installs campaign in this account, Google counts a conversion when a user successfully installs the app from the Google Play Store. That’s it. For the other campaigns, like search or performance max, the conversion event is a full account registration on the website. This means a user has landed on the site, filled out a form with their details, and actively created an account.
An app install is a low-commitment action. It's often an impulse, an "I'll check this out later" thought. A web registration, on the other hand, is a conscious decision to hand over personal information and engage more deeply with the product. One is a tyre-kicker, the other is someone asking to take it for a test drive.
The clearest evidence for this difference in value and intent isn't in the conversion rate, but in the cost. Looking at the data, an app install cost, on average, £0.30. A web registration cost £2.25. That's not a small difference. The market—the auction dynamics of Google Ads—is telling us that acquiring a user who completes a web registration is worth 7.5 times more than one who just installs the app. When you see a 7.5x cost difference, you know you are not comparing the same user action.
Web Registration vs. App Install: A Tale of Two Funnels
Path 1: Web Registration Funnel (High Friction, High Intent)
Ad Click ➔ Landing Page Load ➔ Read & Understand Offer ➔ Fill Registration Form ➔ Submit (Conversion Event). This is a multi-step process requiring active engagement and data entry.
Path 2: App Install Funnel (Low Friction, Impulse Action)
Ad Click ➔ App Store Page ➔ Click "Install" (Conversion Event). This is often a one-click action within a familiar, trusted ecosystem.
So, the massive conversion rate variance isn't a sign that one channel is better. It's a reflection that we are measuring two completely different levels of user commitment. The 49% app install conversion rate is a measure of how good the ad and the store listing are at getting a single click. The web conversion rate is a measure of how good the ad, the landing page, and the offer are at getting someone to complete a multi-step, higher-friction task.
So how much does friction really cost?
Let's quantify this. The journey to a web registration is packed with potential drop-off points. A user sees an ad, they click it. First hurdle: does the landing page load quickly? If not, they're gone. Second hurdle: does the landing page copy clearly explain the value? If it's confusing, they're gone. Third hurdle: can they easily find the sign-up form? Fourth hurdle: is the form asking for too much information? Every additional step, every moment of confusion, sheds users.
The app install path is far more direct. A user sees an ad, they click, land on the app's store page—a standardised, trusted layout they've seen a hundred times—and they click install. The payment and authentication is handled by their device account. It's almost frictionless. The conversion rate reflects this streamlined process. It's not that nearly half of everyone who sees an ad installs the app; it's that a large portion of people who were interested enough to click through to the store page then followed through with the install.
To put this into perspective, a 22-30% conversion rate from an ad click to a completed web registration is actually exceptionally good. It suggests the traffic quality from the search and performance max campaigns is very high, and the landing page is doing a brilliant job of converting that high-intent traffic. Getting a strong percentage of people who click a search ad to complete a full registration is a solid performance. The app install conversion rate isn't better, it's just measuring an easier task.
The interactive diagnostic below helps to visualise this. You can see how even small drop-offs at each stage of a web funnel quickly compound, making the final conversion number seem low. By contrast, the app funnel's simplicity protects its conversion rate.
Funnel Friction & Leakage Diagnostic
See how friction impacts the final number of users. Toggle between the web and app funnel models to see the difference.
Is there a difference in user intent and quality?
This leads to the most important question: are we acquiring the same type of user? Almost certainly not. The data strongly suggests the search and performance max campaigns, which drive web registrations, are capturing users with much higher intent.
Think about the context. The search campaign targets people actively typing keywords like "book scanner app" and "sell books online" into Google. These people have a problem and are actively looking for a solution right now. They are pre-qualified by their own search query. It makes sense that they are more willing to go through a registration process and that they cost more to reach—they are more valuable leads, and you're competing with other businesses for their attention.
The app install campaign, on the other hand, places ads within the store and other apps. The audience is broader. A user might not be actively looking for a book-scanning app, but they see an ad while browsing and decide to tap install. It's a lower-intent, discovery-based acquisition. This is great for volume, but it doesn't guarantee quality or immediate engagement. Many of those £0.30 installs might come from users who open the app once and never return.
The campaign structure itself tells this story. The search campaign is split into ad groups based on intent: high intent, competitors, and broader selling online themes. This is a strategy designed to capture specific, high-value searchers. The app install campaign is a more automated, volume-driven machine. The platform's goal is to find the cheapest possible installs that fit a broad profile, not necessarily the most engaged long-term users.
Cost-Per-User Scenario Simulator
Adjust the monthly ad spend for each campaign type to see how your user acquisition mix impacts your blended Cost Per User.
So, what should you do with this information?
The first thing is to stop directly comparing conversion rates of app install and web registration campaigns. It's a false equivalence. They are measuring different things and acquiring users with different levels of intent. A high conversion rate on an app campaign is not inherently better than a lower conversion rate on a search campaign.
Instead, you need to look further down the funnel. The real test of user quality isn't the initial conversion; it's what happens next. Of those app installs at £0.30 each, how many opened the app? How many completed onboarding? How many converted to a paid subscription? The data shows a 30% free-to-paid conversion rate. If we apply that, the web registrations would generate paid users at a higher true cost per paying customer, while the app installs yield paying customers at a lower cost. On the surface, the app channel still seems far more efficient at acquiring paying customers.
But this assumes the free-to-paid conversion rate is the same for both cohorts. I'd be willing to bet it isn't. The user who actively searched for a solution, navigated a website, and registered an account is likely far more qualified and motivated than the user who impulsively installed an app. It's plausible that the web registration cohort converts to paid at a much higher rate, while the app install cohort converts at a lower rate. The app installs are still cheaper, but the gap narrows significantly. Without that post-install data, we're just guessing.
Your strategy should reflect this reality. Use app install campaigns for what they're good at: driving massive top-of-funnel volume and awareness at a very low cost. It's a great way to fill the top of your funnel. But use your search and other web-focused campaigns to capture high-intent users who are much further along in their buying journey. They cost more, but they are likely to be your best customers.
Below is a searchable table with the raw performance data from the account. You can filter by campaign type to explore the metrics for yourself and see how the cost, click, and conversion numbers vary across the different strategies.
Interactive Campaign Performance Database
Explore the performance breakdown for each campaign in the account. Data covers the period from June 12, 2020 – February 26, 2024.
| Campaign Name | Cost (£) | Conversions | Cost/Conv (£) | Clicks | Conv. Rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| LH - App Installs - Android | 754.90 | 2,490.00 | 0.30 | 5,054 | 49.27% |
| LH Search | 1,538.32 | 592.26 | 2.60 | 2,650 | 22.35% |
| LH - Performance Max | 665.89 | 553.98 | 1.20 | 1,833 | 30.22% |
| LH - TOFU - Discovery | 287.54 | 16.00 | 17.97 | 299 | 5.35% |
| LH - MOFU - Discovery | 140.69 | 6.00 | 23.45 | 141 | 4.26% |
The Final Word: It's a Portfolio, Not a Horse Race
The significant variance in conversion rates between mobile app install and web registration campaigns isn't a sign of one being better than the other. It's a direct result of measuring two fundamentally different user actions, driven by different levels of intent, and involving vastly different levels of friction.
Your app install campaign is a powerful tool for low-cost, high-volume user acquisition. It fills the top of your funnel with users who have expressed a flicker of interest. Your web registration campaigns, particularly those driven by search, are your tools for capturing high-intent prospects who are actively looking for a solution like yours. They are more expensive to acquire, but they are also likely to be your most valuable customers in the long run.
The practical approach is not to pick a winner but to build a balanced portfolio. Use both campaign types strategically for what they do best. And most importantly, stop comparing their front-end conversion rates. Instead, track their performance all the way through to revenue and lifetime value. That's the only way to truly understand which channel is driving real growth for your business.
If you're struggling to make sense of your own campaign data or want to build a more strategic, full-funnel advertising system that focuses on revenue rather than vanity metrics, it might be time to get an expert opinion. We offer a free, no-obligation strategy consultation where we can look at your specific situation and figure out the right approach for you.
Cite this Research & Data
If referencing this research, data, or strategy in your publication, please use the attribution below.
Lukas Holschuh
Founder, Growth & Advertising Consultant
Great campaigns fail without expertise. Lukas and his team provide the missing strategy, optimizing your entire advertising funnel—from ad creatives and copy to landing page design.
Backed by a proven track record across SaaS, eLearning, and eCommerce, they don't just run ads; they engineer systems that convert. A data-driven partnership focused on tangible revenue growth.