TLDR;
- You are likely obsessing over click-through rate (CTR) as a measure of success, assuming a higher CTR always means a better campaign.
- The data from a real-world Google Ads account shows this assumption is incorrect. The campaign with the highest CTR had a cost per conversion 8.7 times higher than the campaign with the best results.
- CTR is only useful as a diagnostic for ad relevance within a specific context (like comparing keywords in one search campaign). It is a poor metric for comparing different campaign types (such as Search versus App Installs).
- This article breaks down the data, with interactive tools to explore how CTR relates to the metrics that actually matter: conversion rate and cost per conversion.
Everyone seems to be chasing a higher click-through rate. It is one of the first metrics people look at in their ad accounts, and there is a common belief that if you can just increase your CTR, everything else will fall into place. It feels good to see a high number there, signaling that your ads are resonating and that people are interested.
Does a high CTR actually lead to what we are all really after – more customers at a lower cost? Or is it just another vanity metric that looks good in a report but fails to help the bottom line? This question comes up frequently, so I conducted a thorough review of a Google Ads account we managed for a SaaS client to see what the data actually reveals. Forget industry blog posts recycling the same old advice; let us examine the raw numbers from a single, complete account.
The dataset used for this investigation comes from one place: the Google Ads account for an app called ScoutIQ. It is a tool for people who sell books online, helping them scan books to check their value. We ran ads for them over an extended period, from mid-2020 to early 2024, spending a total of £3,387.34. While not a massive budget, it represents a complete, self-contained dataset across multiple campaign types, making it ideal for this kind of analysis. We can observe exactly how different strategies performed under the same roof, for the same product. My goal is to use this data to find a practical answer regarding where CTR fits into a successful advertising strategy.
So how much does CTR actually vary between campaigns?
The first logical step is to lay out the numbers. How different can CTRs be when running different types of campaigns for the same product? The ScoutIQ account had five distinct campaigns running: a standard Search campaign, a Performance Max campaign, an App Installs campaign targeting Android users, and two Demand Gen campaigns, one for top-of-funnel (TOFU) and one for retargeting (MOFU).
When you put their performance side-by-side, the difference in CTR is stark. It is not a small variation; it represents entirely different engagement levels depending on where the ads are displayed.
Click-Through Rate by Campaign Type
Click-Through Rate (CTR) comparison across five distinct Google Ads campaign types run for the ScoutIQ app, based on performance data from June 2020 to February 2024.
Search campaigns, which target users actively typing in keywords like "book scanner app," achieve the highest CTR at 9.51%. These users are looking for a solution, making them more likely to click on a relevant ad. Performance Max, a hybrid campaign type running across Google inventory, ranks second at 7.17%. App Installs, which primarily appear in the Google Play store and on YouTube, sit in the middle at 4.97%.
Then there is a significant drop-off. The Demand Gen campaigns, designed to reach people based on interests and online behavior (placements on YouTube, Discover, and Gmail), both recorded a 1.39% CTR. This is typical for display-style advertising where user attention is interrupted rather than answering a direct query.
Looking at this chart, the obvious conclusion might be to allocate all ad spend to Search ads since they generate the most clicks per impression. However, this surface-level mindset often leads advertisers astray.
If high CTR is the goal, why wasn't the Search campaign our best performer?
A click is just a click and does not generate revenue by itself. The primary objective is conversions—in this instance, a user either installing the app or registering for an account on the website. Examining the cost per conversion (Cost per Acquisition, CPA) for each campaign alongside their CTR reveals the limitation of relying solely on click rates.
CTR vs. Cost Per Conversion: The Real Story
A side-by-side comparison of Click-Through Rate (CTR) and Cost Per Conversion (£) across the five Google Ads campaign types. This table reveals the disconnect between click engagement and actual acquisition cost.
| Campaign Type | Click-Through Rate (CTR) | Cost Per Conversion | Total Conversions |
|---|---|---|---|
| LH - App Installs - Android | 4.97% | £0.30 | 2,490 |
| LH - Performance Max | 7.17% | £1.20 | 554 |
| LH Search | 9.51% | £2.60 | 592 |
| LH - TOFU - Discovery | 1.39% | £17.97 | 16 |
| LH - MOFU - Discovery | 1.39% | £23.45 | 6 |
The Search campaign, achieving a 9.51% CTR, delivered conversions at £2.60 each. However, the App Installs campaign recorded a lower CTR of 4.97% while acquiring new users for just £0.30 each—8.7 times cheaper.
Chasing high CTR would have diverted all budget into the Search campaign while ignoring the most efficient engine for user growth. The Demand Gen campaigns, with low CTRs, yielded high CPAs of £17.97 and £23.45 due to unready audiences. Conversely, the App Installs campaign demonstrates that an average CTR does not indicate poor campaign viability.
User intent drives these differences. A person searching the Google Play store operates in a different mindset compared to someone on Google.com. The path from click to install contains less friction within the app store environment. Although fewer people clicked the ad (lower CTR), a larger percentage of those clicks resulted in app installs (higher conversion rate).
This highlights the limitation of focusing solely on CTR. It measures only the initial step and provides no insight into click quality or subsequent actions. Comparing the CTR of a Search campaign to an App campaign involves different environments and conversion paths.
So when is CTR actually a useful metric?
CTR remains a valuable diagnostic tool when applied correctly to compare like with like. Its strength lies in measuring ad relevance within a single, consistent context, such as comparing keywords and ad groups inside a Search campaign.
Reviewing the `LH Search` campaign structure reveals how ad groups map to user intent:
- BOFU (Bottom of Funnel): Targeting the brand name "ScoutIQ" and direct competitors for users who know what they want.
- MOFU (Middle of Funnel): Targeting high-intent phrases like "book scanner app" for users looking for solutions.
- TOFU (Top of Funnel): Targeting broad terms like "sell books online" for users exploring related goals.
Examining the CTR across these ad groups reveals a pattern aligned with user intent.
Search Ad Group Performance Database
Explore the performance of different ad groups within the Search campaign. Sort the columns to see the relationship between user intent, CTR, and cost per conversion. Notice how higher-intent ad groups generally have higher CTRs.
| Ad Group (Intent) | CTR | Cost / Conv. | Conv. Rate | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| LH BOFU Brand keywords (phrase match) | 16.67% | £1.75 | N/A | £41.97 |
| LH MOFU High Intent (phrase match) | 10.63% | £2.77 | 18.65% | £305.29 |
| LH TOFU Selling Online (broad match) | 9.69% | £2.55 | 21.57% | £1,104.43 |
| LH BOFU Competitors (phrase match) | 6.23% | £3.55 | 6.35% | £83.78 |
| LH TOFU Amazon Seller Tools (phrase match) | 0.86% | £2.97 | 16.67% | £2.97 |
The Brand ad group achieved a 16.67% CTR, reflecting high qualification among users searching for the company name. The High Intent group followed with a 10.63% CTR, while the broad Selling Online group recorded 9.69%. The Competitors group registered a 6.23% CTR, demonstrating the difficulty of drawing users away from alternative brands.
In this context, CTR functions effectively as a relevance proxy. Higher relevance to the searcher's immediate need correlates with higher CTR and generally aligns with cost per conversion efficiency, evidenced by the Brand group achieving the lowest CPA at £1.75.
Using CTR as a feedback mechanism allows advertisers to identify mismatches when an ad group's CTR drops significantly below comparable groups, prompting reviews of keywords or messaging.
Can optimising for CTR hurt your overall performance?
Strategic decisions made to reduce cost per conversion can occasionally cause blended CTR to decline, which appears counterintuitive if top-line CTR is the primary focus.
Reviewing monthly performance from October 2023 to January 2024 shows budget reallocation away from lower-efficiency campaigns toward top performers like App Installs and Performance Max.
The Danger of Blended Metrics
This chart plots the account's overall blended CPA and CTR over a four-month optimisation period. As we shifted budget to more efficient campaigns, the overall CPA plummeted, while the blended CTR fluctuated without a clear positive trend. This shows how optimising for profit can sometimes make top-line metrics look worse.
Blended Cost Per Acquisition Trend
Blended CTR Trend
Overall cost per conversion decreased from £2.45 in October to £0.67 in January. Blended CTR peaked in November at 6.13% before drifting down to 5.92% in January. Evaluating performance solely on declining CTR would suggest worsening results, while profitability increased.
Directing more budget to the App Installs campaign pulled down the account average CTR due to that campaign's lower CTR baseline (4.97%), trading top-line CTR for a substantial gain in bottom-line efficiency.
An interactive calculator below models how shifting budget between a high-CTR/high-CPA campaign and a low-CTR/low-CPA campaign affects blended metrics, demonstrating how lower blended CTR can accompany improved acquisition costs.
Budget Allocation Impact Simulator
Use the slider to shift a £1,000 budget between a high-CTR campaign (like Search) and a low-CPA campaign (like App Installs) to observe the impact on blended account metrics.
What steps should you take moving forward?
The evidence from this real-world account demonstrates that chasing high click-through rates as an independent goal can encourage a focus on metrics with inverse relationships to profitability.
I have detailed my main recommendations for you below:
- Define Your Real Goal: Identify the user action that drives revenue, whether it is a sale, lead, app install, or trial sign-up. The cost and volume associated with that action serve as primary metrics.
- Use CTR as a Diagnostic, Not a Goal: Evaluate ad group health using CTR within a single campaign to compare similar targeting contexts and identify messaging mismatches.
- Stop Comparing Different Formats: Recognize that disparate placements maintain varying baseline CTRs driven by unique user intents.
- Trust the CPA: Let cost per conversion guide budget allocation. Scale campaigns delivering profitable conversions regardless of their headline CTR.
Platform dashboards often emphasize metrics like CTR due to simplicity, but effective advertising prioritizes relevant engagement and customer acquisition over raw clicks.
Analyzing campaign data and establishing strategy can be challenging. If you are reviewing your own campaigns and want clarity on metric reliability or scaling strategies, scheduling a free consultation allows us to review your account together and outline a data-driven path forward.
Cite this Research & Data
If referencing this research, data, or strategy in your publication, please use the attribution below.
Lukas Holschuh
Founder, Growth & Advertising Consultant
Great campaigns fail without expertise. Lukas and his team provide the missing strategy, optimizing your entire advertising funnel—from ad creatives and copy to landing page design.
Backed by a proven track record across SaaS, eLearning, and eCommerce, they don't just run ads; they engineer systems that convert. A data-driven partnership focused on tangible revenue growth.