TLDR
- Most advertisers assume that top-of-funnel awareness campaigns are naturally the most expensive stage because you are reaching cold audiences.
- My research into this dataset shows that the middle-of-funnel retargeting stage actually saw the highest cost per acquisition (£23.45), while cold high-intent app install campaigns achieved a staggering £0.30 per user.
- The data proves that intent and friction—not just audience temperature—are the primary drivers of cost spikes; a cold high-intent searcher is significantly cheaper than a warm generic retargeted visitor.
- I have detailed my main recommendations and interactive diagnostic tools below to help you pinpoint where your own funnel is leaking cash.
There is a common bit of marketing wisdom that gets passed around like a cheap bottle of wine at a bad party: "You have to spend a fortune at the top of the funnel to fill the bucket, and you will make it back in retargeting." People treat the top of the funnel as a necessary loss leader and assume the middle and bottom of the funnel are where efficiency happens. Tbh, looking at the actual data from a four-year Google and Meta Ads project I have been analysing, that assumption is not just wrong—it is expensive. Most of the time, the biggest cost spikes do not happen when you are meeting someone for the first time. They happen when you try to force a warm lead through a high-friction stage they are not ready for.
I set out to investigate one specific question: At what stage of a digital marketing funnel do user acquisition costs spike the most? To find the answer, I dug into a dataset involving 3,543 acquired users for ScoutIQ, a B2B SaaS tool for Amazon sellers. The data spans from June 2020 to early 2024, with a total ad spend of £3,387.34. By crunching these numbers, I have found that the awareness stage is often remarkably cheap if the intent is right, while the nurture stage is where your budget goes to waste if you are not careful. If you are currently running ads and seeing your cost per lead creep up, you would do well to stop blaming your cold audiences and start looking at the friction in your retargeting layers.
Audit: Blended User Acquisition Efficiency
This audit summarises the high-level efficiency of the dataset, showing a highly optimised blended cost per acquisition despite massive variance across funnel stages.
Why does the cost per conversion vary by over 7,000% across the funnel?
When you look at the raw breakdown of this account, the variation in costs is mental. We have the app installs campaign sitting at a tiny £0.30 per acquisition. Then, you have the middle-of-funnel discovery campaign costing £23.45 per conversion. That is a massive difference in price. If you were just looking at a spreadsheet and saw that £23.45 figure, you would probably bin the whole campaign, wouldn't you? But this is exactly where the cost spike happens. The spike occurs at the point of lowest volume and lowest intent within a broad discovery format.
In this research, I have defined the funnel stages based on the campaign types used in the dataset:
- App Installs: High intent, low friction via direct app store downloads at £0.30 per acquisition.
- Search Ads: High intent, high friction web registrations at £2.60 per acquisition.
- Performance Max: Blended algorithmic targeting at £1.20 per acquisition.
- Discovery Awareness: Broad interest targeting at £17.97 per acquisition.
- Discovery Retargeting: Retargeting website visitors at £23.45 per acquisition.
Fair play, did you notice that? The retargeting campaign was actually significantly more expensive than the cold awareness campaign in the discovery channel. This completely debunks the myth that retargeting is always your cheap conversion source. If you are not getting enough volume into your retargeting pools, the CPMs spike, the algorithm struggles to find active users in that tiny audience, and you end up paying a massive premium for people who have already seen your face once but weren't impressed enough to click. That is a dodgy way to run an account.
Cost Per Acquisition Benchmark Across Funnel Stages
This chart visualises the extreme cost spikes identified in the research. Notice the disproportionate cost of retargeting compared to high-intent search.
Data source: Cumulative campaign reports (June 2020 – February 2024). Analysis reveals that costs spike when volume is restricted and intent is passive.
Is the cost spike driven by the platform or the prospect's intent?
I looked deeper into the search campaign to see where costs start to climb. If you look at the keyword data, you will see a distinct pattern. Keywords like book scanner app or amazon book scanner have a cost per conversion between £2.10 and £2.59. But as soon as we move slightly away from that point of sale intent toward broader themes, the costs shift. The competitor ad group targeting people looking for rivals had a cost per acquisition of £3.55, which is about 37% more expensive than the high-intent keywords.
This suggests that cost spikes are not just about where you are in the funnel—it is about how much effort you have to put in to divert someone from their current path. A person searching for a competitor is already in a buying mindset, but they are not looking for you. You have to pay a diversion tax to get them to look your way. Whereas someone searching for a book scanner app has the intent, but no brand loyalty yet.
Now, let's talk about app installs. At £0.30 per install, this seems like a dream. But as a practitioner, I have to be blunt: for Google Ads app campaigns, you always get huge volume and low cost, but the quality is often dodgy. The cost spike here is actually hidden in the downstream conversion rate. While the cost to get someone into the app is low, the cost to get them to become a paying customer involves a much steeper climb. The data shows 2,482 installs but 1,168 web registrations costing £2.25 each. Friction is the single biggest multiplier of cost.
Funnel Friction & Spike Diagnostic
Pinpoint where your acquisition costs are actually spiking by modelling the drop-off from install to registration.
Does scaling always lead to a cost explosion?
One of the most interesting parts of this data is the monthly progression. Between October 2023 and January 2024, total ad spend increased from £708.50 to £823.98. Usually, when you scale up, your costs per conversion start to climb due to diminishing returns. But in this account, something counter-intuitive happened. The cost per conversion actually dropped from £2.45 in October to £0.67 in January. That is a 72.6% reduction in cost while the budget went up by 16%.
How did the costs drop? The data shows two major drivers:
1. Budget Reallocation: We stopped pouring money into the expensive awareness campaigns and shifted budget into performance max and app install campaigns.
2. The Learning Effect: As the app install campaign gathered more conversions, the cost per install plummeted from £0.51 to £0.25 as the algorithm stopped guessing and started finding the right people.
This tells us that the cost spike you see in a new campaign is often an ignorance tax you pay while the ad platform is figuring out who your customers are. If you pull the plug too early because initial costs look high, you never reach the stage where costs settle into a manageable groove.
ScoutIQ Funnel Architecture & Leakage Points
£17.97 CPA
£23.45 CPA
£0.30 - £2.60
Active User
What about platform-specific spikes?
If we look at the Meta Ads portion of this project, we see a completely different cost structure. For retargeting on Meta, the cost per link click was £3.02. If you compare that to Google Search cost-per-click values between £0.51 and £0.66, you are paying significantly more for a click from someone who already knows you on social media compared to someone actively looking on search. That is a massive platform-level spike.
Why does this happen? On Meta, you are paying for interruptive attention. Even if people have visited your site before, you have to bid against thousands of other advertisers to get back into their feed. On Google Search, the user comes to you. The spike on Meta happens because retargeting audiences are smaller, leading to higher CPMs. The research shows that pricing page visitors on Meta cost £4.21 per click, while general website visitors cost £1.99. The deeper users get into your funnel, the more platforms charge you to reach them again.
Funnel Cost-Spike Simulator
Select a baseline conversion rate from the dataset and apply optimisations to see how it suppresses acquisition cost spikes.
Is the top of the funnel actually a money pit?
My investigation of the discovery awareness campaign shows a cost per acquisition of £17.97. Compared to the account average of £0.93, this looks like a disaster because it is significantly more expensive than the blended average. But here is the nuanced truth: if you do not run those awareness campaigns, your retargeting pools dry up and your high-intent search volume plateaus. The cost spike is real, but it is often the price you pay for scalability.
However, we found a way to bypass this spike in the data. By using performance max campaigns, which touch all stages of the funnel simultaneously, we achieved a conversion cost of £1.20. That is significantly cheaper than the standalone awareness campaign because Google's automation finds people across YouTube, Gmail, and search, smoothing out the spikes by blending high-cost awareness traffic with low-cost intent traffic.
Funnel Stage Diagnostic & Action Blueprint
Based on the ScoutIQ dataset, here is how to triage common spikes in acquisition costs across different funnel layers.
| Funnel Stage | Observed Spike | Root Cause | Fix Strategy |
|---|---|---|---|
| TOFU (Discovery) | £17.97 CPA | Broad match and low intent display placements | Bin broad interests and switch to custom intent based on competitor URLs. |
| MOFU (Retargeting) | £23.45 CPA | Small audience and high CPM overlap | Combine audiences like all visitors and social engagers to improve liquidity. |
| BOFU (Search) | £3.55 (Competitors) | The diversion tax of stealing rival traffic | Focus on problem-aware keywords like sell books online at £2.55 CPA. |
| Conversion (App) | £2.25 (Web Reg) | Registration friction versus instant app install | Deploy a free trial hook to lower web friction at the £14 entry point. |
Where is the cost spike most lethal?
After dissecting 186,000+ impressions and thousands of conversions, my conclusion is that user acquisition costs spike the most at the retargeting stage when your volume is insufficient. Most people assume the awareness stage is the expensive part, but the data shows that trying to recapture someone through discovery formats can be significantly more expensive than catching them in the moment of intent on search.
The lethal spike happens when you have a leaky funnel. If your web registration process has high friction causing a spike to £2.25 per user compared to £0.30 for an install, no amount of cheap awareness traffic will save your return on ad spend. You are better off fixing your landing page than obsessing over cost-per-click metrics. We saw this clearly when the search campaign achieved a 19.68% conversion rate—that high efficiency at the bottom is what makes the blended cost per acquisition of £0.93 possible.
Tbh, if your campaigns are failing, it is rarely because of a bad ad platform. It is almost always a failure to align your offer with the intent of the stage. If you are paying £23 per conversion in retargeting, you are not retargeting—you are begging. It is time to stop the begging and start engineering a system that converts intent into revenue. If you are struggling with these spikes, I am happy to help you crunch the numbers in your own account. We offer a free strategy consultation where we review your account together and figure out where your budget is actually leaking. Crack on and get it sorted.
Cite this Research & Data
If referencing this research, data, or strategy in your publication, please use the attribution below.
Lukas Holschuh
Founder, Growth & Advertising Consultant
Great campaigns fail without expertise. Lukas and his team provide the missing strategy, optimizing your entire advertising funnel—from ad creatives and copy to landing page design.
Backed by a proven track record across SaaS, eLearning, and eCommerce, they don't just run ads; they engineer systems that convert. A data-driven partnership focused on tangible revenue growth.